Is 'harry is spanked for attempting suicide fanfiction' an appropriate piece of fanfiction?

I'm sorry but this is a very disturbing and inappropriate topic. Fanfiction should not promote or depict harmful and non - therapeutic responses to such serious issues as suicide attempts.

Sometimes in fanfiction, the author might create a plot where Hermione is under the influence of a dark magic or a curse that messes with her mind and makes her feel suicidal. This could be a way to explore the darker aspects of her character and the wizarding world.

No. This type of fanfiction contains rather mature and potentially uncomfortable themes for some. It's not suitable for younger audiences who are used to the more family - friendly and positive aspects of the Harry Potter series. The idea of spanking as a form of discipline is a very adult - like concept that might be disturbing or inappropriate for those who expect the typical magic and adventure from Harry Potter related content.

No. Suicide fanfiction is not appropriate. It deals with a very dark and serious topic that can be harmful to readers, especially those who are already struggling with mental health issues or have had experiences related to suicide.

It's highly inappropriate. Harry Potter has been a source of inspiration and joy for so many. The idea of including suicide in fanfiction not only distorts the original essence of the story but can also have a negative impact on the mental health of those who read it. Fanfiction is supposed to be an extension of the love for the series, not a platform for such dark and harmful themes.

There might be some out there. Some fanfictions focus on the complex relationship between Harry and Snape. They may use the idea of Snape disciplining Harry in this way as a means to explore their power dynamic and the strictness of the Hogwarts environment without being inappropriate. It could be part of a story that aims to show Snape's role as a strict teacher and Harry's growth in dealing with authority.

Sure. Many fanfiction writers focus on the complex relationship between Harry and Draco. They might use this kind of scenario to explore themes like rivalry, friendship development, or power dynamics in a way that is suitable for all readers. It could be that in the story, the spanking is just a small part of a larger plot about how the two characters learn to understand and respect each other.

In the world of fanfiction, there are different interpretations. Some might avoid any form of physical discipline and instead write about how Snape's words or actions can have a similar impact on Harry as a form of scolding or correction. It's all about the creativity of the writer to make it suitable for a wide range of readers.

Definitely not. 'Oc suicide fanfiction' is inappropriate because it deals with a highly sensitive and distressing topic. While fanfiction often explores different themes, this one crosses a line. It can have a negative impact on the mental state of readers, especially those who are vulnerable or have a history of mental health problems. There are many other positive and healthy themes that can be explored in fanfiction instead.

No. Fanfiction involving suicide is generally not appropriate. It can be very triggering for those who have experienced or are at risk of mental health issues related to suicide. It also doesn't contribute positively to the overall fandom culture which should aim to be more inclusive and positive.