What Are the Reasons for Sirius Black Being a Death Eater in Fanfiction?

In some fanfiction, Sirius Black might be wrongly portrayed as a Death Eater for the sake of creating an alternative or dark storyline. But in the original 'Harry Potter' series, he is not a Death Eater at all. He was framed by Peter Pettigrew.

One reason could be to add more conflict within the Weasley family. Percy was already somewhat of an outcast in the family due to his loyalty to the Ministry. Turning him into a Death Eater would intensify that divide.

One interesting Sirius Black as a Death Eater fanfiction could be 'The Darkened Path of Sirius'. In this story, Sirius might be forced into the Death Eater ranks due to some dark family secrets. Another could be 'Sirius's Fall and Redemption'. It might explore how being a Death Eater changes him and his journey back to the good side. And 'The Alternative Sirius' could show a world where Sirius is a Death Eater from the start, changing the whole dynamic of the Harry Potter universe.

One possible scenario in such a fanfiction could be that Sirius is somehow forced or tricked into becoming a Death Eater. Hermione might then try to rescue him from the dark side. Maybe she discovers some ancient magic that can reverse the dark mark's influence on him.

Another idea is that Sirius, as a Death Eater, has some information that Hermione needs to defeat Voldemort. She has to convince him to give it to her while also dealing with his newfound allegiance. It could be a race against time as other Death Eaters suspect Sirius of being unfaithful to their cause, and Hermione has to protect him while also getting the crucial information.

One reason could be the strong bond between them in the original story. Fanfic writers might think that making them father - son would enhance that bond further. Also, Sirius was a very important figure in Harry's life, so it makes for an interesting twist.

One reason could be the strong bond between them in the original story. Fans might have felt that it could be developed into a father - son relationship in fanfic.

It could be due to Dumbledore's decisions regarding Harry. Sirius is very protective of Harry. If he thinks Dumbledore is using Harry in some way for the greater good without fully considering Harry's well - being, he would be fed up. For instance, Dumbledore's decisions about Harry's participation in the Triwizard Tournament could be a point of contention for Sirius.

Another possibility is that he is in love with her. In fanfiction, love can be a powerful motivator. He might be attracted to her intelligence, her strong will, and her beauty. This love could override his loyalty to the Dark Lord and make him want to protect her at all costs. He could see her as a symbol of hope and a better future for the wizarding world.

It could also be that Hermione is on a mission to gather information. By helping the Death Eater, she hopes to gain insider knowledge about the Death Eater's group or their plans. This would be a strategic move on her part, using the situation to her advantage in the fight against the dark forces.