It could be a rogue demigod who has discovered the secret of the lemon's power in relation to Percy and Poseidon. He wants to use it to gain ultimate power over the sea and all demigods associated with it. He would constantly be creating obstacles for Percy and Poseidon to keep them from using the lemon's power for good.
A powerful water nymph could be the main antagonist. Maybe she's jealous of the special bond between Percy and Poseidon and the power of the lemon. So she tries to steal the lemon and use its power to take over Poseidon's domain.
A powerful Titan who has a grudge against Poseidon could be a great antagonist. This Titan might be trying to undermine Poseidon's power by targeting his first - born, Percy.
A powerful Titan who sees Percy as a threat to his plans. Since Percy has the power of Zeus and Poseidon, he could potentially stop any chaos the Titan wants to create. The Titan might try to turn Percy's friends against him or find a way to strip him of his powers.
The main antagonist could be a powerful sorcerer who has found a way to enter the Percy Jackson game world. He has his own motives, perhaps he wants to steal the powers of the demigods for himself. He's able to manipulate the game's code to his advantage, creating illusions and false paths for Percy and his friends to follow. Or it could be an ancient spirit that was sealed away in the game but has been released. This spirit is angry at the gods and demigods and wants to destroy everything they hold dear. Also, a group of bandit demigods could be the main antagonists. They don't follow the rules of the game or the real - world demigod society and are causing chaos everywhere they go, trying to steal valuable items from both the game world and the real - world locations.
A powerful sorcerer from another realm who uses assassins as tools. This sorcerer could see Percy as a threat to their plans of taking over the demigod world. They send their best assassins after Percy and also try to manipulate other demigods against him. They are extremely cunning and have a vast array of dark magic at their disposal.
Nyx could be a great main antagonist. She's a primordial goddess of the night and Tartarus is her domain in a way. She might see Percy and his friends as intruders and try to stop them from leaving or achieving their goals. She could use her power over darkness and the unknown to create all sorts of obstacles for them.
The main antagonist could be a powerful Titan who wants to use Percy as a weapon to overthrow the Olympian gods. The Titan might see Percy's unique powers as a weapon as the perfect tool to gain ultimate power and reshape the world according to his own desires.
It could be a new, powerful Titan that has emerged from the depths of Tartarus. This Titan might be seeking revenge on the demigods for imprisoning the other Titans and sees Hylla and Percy as the biggest threats.
One possible plot could be Percy discovers a hidden underwater grotto dedicated to Poseidon where he finds a magical lemon tree. The lemons have special powers that are only revealed when Percy and Poseidon interact near it. They could then go on an adventure to protect the grotto from a sea monster that wants to destroy it for its own gain.
It could be an old enemy of Percy's who sees his relationship with Goddess Lemon as a threat. Maybe a Titan or a powerful monster that wants to use their relationship to its advantage, like using it to create a rift among the gods and demigods.
It could be an ancient sea god who has been forgotten but now wants to reclaim his former glory. He sees Percy's ocean soul as a key to achieving that and will stop at nothing to get it from him, causing chaos in the process.