Perhaps it has unlikable characters. They could be really one - dimensional or act in ways that don't make sense. Like a character who is supposed to be kind but then is randomly cruel for no reason. Another factor could be that it just doesn't capture the spirit of MLP at all. It might be too dark or too different from the positive and friendly vibe that MLP usually has.
It might also be that the fanfic is full of clichés and overused tropes. Instead of coming up with something original, it just recycles the same old ideas that we've seen a million times before. And the dialogue could be really stilted and unnatural, making it hard for the reader to get into the story.
Well, one reason could be the complete disregard for the established Pokemon lore. For example, giving Pokemon abilities that are completely out of character or making them behave in ways that go against their known natures in the official games and anime. Another aspect could be the poor writing quality, like having a lot of grammar and spelling mistakes that make it really hard to read and enjoy. Also, some might make the plot overly complicated or just really dull, not capturing the essence of what makes Pokemon interesting in the first place.
Well, it could be a bunch of things. Maybe the writing is really poor, like full of grammar mistakes and choppy sentences. Or perhaps the plot doesn't make any sense at all. It might also be that the characters are completely out of character, not at all like how they are in the original source material.
One reason could be the poor writing skills. Maybe the grammar and spelling are all over the place. It can also be due to a lack of understanding of the original source material. For example, the characters' personalities are completely distorted. Another aspect is that the plot might be extremely unoriginal or full of clichés, like the typical 'love triangle' done in a really cheesy way.
Another aspect could be that the two people in the love story are constantly fighting and not able to resolve their differences. They may have different values, like one values family a great deal while the other is a workaholic and doesn't care about family time. This clash of values can lead to a really bad and unfulfilling love story.
Well, it could be bad because of the poor writing. Maybe the grammar and spelling are all over the place. Also, if it doesn't stay true to the characters' personalities from the original Danganronpa, that can be a major turn - off. For example, if a normally calm character is suddenly made overly aggressive without any proper explanation in the fan fiction.
For some like 'The Crystal Star', it's the overly complex and uninteresting plot. It gets so convoluted that it's hard for readers to stay engaged. Others like 'Darksaber' have poor character development. The characters seem flat and their actions don't always make sense in the context of the Star Wars universe. And then there are novels where the writing style is just not up to par, like in 'The Courtship of Princess Leia' where the story seems more like a strange fanfiction rather than a proper Star Wars story.
Maybe it's the lack of clear messaging or poor drawing skills. Sometimes, the themes they try to convey just don't come across well.
The combination of two different universes. It's like mixing two different flavors to create a new and exciting taste. SkyDoesMinecraft has its own fan base and My Little Pony has its own, and when they are combined in fanfic, it attracts fans from both.
The character of Scootaloo herself makes the fanfic interesting. She has this underdog quality as she struggles with not being able to fly as easily as other pegasi. Fanfic writers can explore her determination and growth in different scenarios.
The popularity of MLP period fanfic can be attributed to the rich world of My Little Pony. Fans love to explore different periods within this universe. It allows them to expand on the existing lore and create their own stories.