What makes a Pokemon fanfiction 'bad'?

Well, one reason could be the complete disregard for the established Pokemon lore. For example, giving Pokemon abilities that are completely out of character or making them behave in ways that go against their known natures in the official games and anime. Another aspect could be the poor writing quality, like having a lot of grammar and spelling mistakes that make it really hard to read and enjoy. Also, some might make the plot overly complicated or just really dull, not capturing the essence of what makes Pokemon interesting in the first place.

Maybe the plot is just all over the place. In some horrible Pokemon fanfiction, the story might start with a Pokemon training adventure and then suddenly turn into some crazy alien invasion where Pokemon have nothing to do with their original abilities. There's no coherence or logical progression, which makes it a mess.

Well, in certain fanfictions, Ash's inexperience in handling different Pokémon species can make him seem like a bad trainer. He may not be aware of the specific training methods required for some Pokémon. For instance, he might treat a very delicate and rare Pokémon the same way he treats his more common ones, which could lead to the Pokémon not reaching its full potential.

One reason could be the poor writing skills. Bad grammar, misspelled words, and clumsy sentence structures can make it really hard to read. For example, if a fanfiction has sentences that don't make sense or words used in the wrong context, it just ruins the whole experience.

Good character development is key. If the fanfiction involves other Pokemon characters along with Jirachi, how they interact and grow throughout the story is important. It could be about a trainer's journey with Jirachi and how both of them change over time. The plot should also be engaging. Maybe it's a mystery involving Jirachi's wishes or an adventure where Jirachi has to use its powers to save the day. A well - paced plot keeps the readers hooked.

RWBY's story structure is a factor. It has a tendency to introduce a lot of elements and characters but then struggle to manage them all effectively. This is a common problem in bad fanfiction where the author bites off more than they can chew. There are so many different plotlines and sub - plots in RWBY that it can be overwhelming and confusing, just like a messy fan - written story.

Well, a bad Harry Potter fanfiction could be due to bad world - building. In the Harry Potter series, the world of Hogwarts and the wizarding world is so richly detailed. If a fanfiction fails to capture that essence or creates a really inconsistent world, it's bad. For instance, if the houses at Hogwarts suddenly have completely different characteristics that don't align with what J.K. Rowling created. Additionally, if the fanfiction has a really forced or contrived plot device just to get to a certain point, like a deus ex machina that solves all the problems out of nowhere, it's a sign of a bad fanfiction.

In Pokemon fanfiction, the setting can also contribute to Pokemon being seen as just monsters. If the story is set in a post - apocalyptic or a very wild and lawless world, Pokemon may be forced to act more like monsters to survive. For example, in a world where food is scarce, Pokemon might fight each other brutally for resources, and in such a context, they would be easily perceived as just monsters rather than the more nuanced creatures we know from the official Pokemon universe.

The unique art - creating ability of Smeargle in the Pokemon world. Fanfictions often explore this aspect in creative ways, like Smeargle using its Sketch move to create amazing things or getting into adventures related to its artistic skills.

Character development is also key. If there are new characters introduced in the fanfiction, they should be believable and have their own personalities. And for the existing Pokemon characters, like Jirachi, they should be portrayed accurately. Also, the writing style should be engaging. If it's too dull or hard to follow, it won't be a great fanfiction. Good use of description to bring the Pokemon world to life, like describing Jirachi's cute appearance and magical powers, can make a big difference.