Who would win in a fight between Roger and Whitebeard in the manga?

I think Whitebeard has a better chance. His devil fruit powers and combat experience gave him a significant edge. However, Akainu shouldn't be underestimated either.

It's hard to say for sure. Both Whitebeard and Blackbeard are incredibly powerful. Whitebeard has his immense strength and experience, while Blackbeard has his devious tactics and unique abilities. It could go either way depending on the circumstances.

It's hard to say for sure. Both are incredibly powerful, but Whitebeard's experience and raw strength might give him an edge.

Whitebeard might have the edge. His power and experience were legendary.

Whitebeard might have the edge. His powers and experience give him a strong advantage.

Whitebeard might have the upper hand. His power and experience are immense.

It's a tough call. Akainu has his own powerful devil fruit abilities, but Whitebeard's reputation and combat skills give him an edge. However, the outcome could also depend on various factors like the situation and strategy.

It's hard to say for sure. Both Kaido and Whitebeard are incredibly powerful. Kaido is known for his durability and raw strength, while Whitebeard has immense power and battle experience.

It's a tough call. Blackbeard is cunning and has gained powerful devil fruit abilities, but Whitebeard's raw power and reputation make him a strong contender. In the end, it might depend on various factors like the circumstances and strategies employed.

It's hard to say for sure. Both Garp, Roger, and Rocks are incredibly powerful, and the outcome would depend on various factors like their current conditions and strategies.