Reviews of I Reincarnated As A Stick by TrueDawn - Webnovel

It has been a year since I made my first review of this novel, and I just realized that I didn't talk about the plot of the novel at all. Here's an updated review just for that sole reason. Aurus used to be a God-level player of ISE, who was chosen by Kurohana, the Greater Goddess of Reincarnation, to become the main part of her masterwork weapon. He dies, Kurohana reincarnates him, and he becomes a stick. Of course, he doesn't just become an ordinary stick. He becomes a stick...with a system! With this system, he actually becomes...a stronger stick! ...what? You were expecting some powerful being instead? He does become incredibly powerful, but I suggest you read the novel. Have fun!

I must say(since everyone starts out thinking the same way with this novel due to the uniqueness of it), I didn't expect this novel to be as grand as it is becoming. It is truly a well thought out concept, and it wonderfully encompasses the idea of an isekai in the most rediculous and tasteful of fashions. Before I begin my review, my rating is completely accurate. When I started out reading, I was like... "What is this stick going to do, roll over its enemies? ", and behold, that was legit the first thing the MC did!! I was like, "Well, my expectations have been met. Add to favorites." Within 15 days, I got to current and I am excited for each new release. The character development for this novel is a bit confusing to get at first, but soon you will fall in love with the sayings and quirks of the characters. One might even begin to "ship sticks", and that thought is just freaking wild lol. Overall, you will love and hate certain characters at different times, and maybe even disagree with how the MC does certain things; however, this only adds to the reading experience, let me assure you. The story development is far from being a finished product, even at its current point(272). Even so, while some may see this story as slow, it is all leading to a larger, more grand and more defined picture. This novel, currently, is in Volume 4, so finding out there are story arcs... It blew my mind to think a "stick story" could get so far, AND IT'S NOT STOPPING! With consistent and daily updates, along with an author who listens to the comments and consistently improves upon the work as a whole, it is very encouraging to see a story and the world develop more and more, day by day. I have found myself laughing over certain scenarios, amazed by the world building and descriptions of locations, and even enticed by the battles between sticks lol. (trust me, rolling is just the start...) If you have the opportunity to get as far as me, I recommend joining the discord. It's one fun time in there, for sure. Tldr; if you enjoy a captivating and wild, but a completely unexpected story filled with adventure, looming danger, phenomenal character development, and modernized humor for those relief moments- - Please, check out this novel. You won't regret it :)

To be honest I'm only writing this review, that is likely to be lost in the sea of other reviews, because I don't see a lot of people actually reviewing the book. It was either people just going off on a tangent, labeling the their most frustrating scenes in the book, using a myriad of offensive words to describe it, or Just plain old white Knighting. There is also a large block of text dedicated to fans that are enjoying the book, which to be honest is pretty nice. At least I don't have to deal with a copiously long toxic comment with no constructive criticism to be seen. It also shows that a large portion of the community has some patience. Now (disclaimer!!!!!), I never really made it past the first 50 reviews. There are too many to read. Second (Disclaimer!!!), If someone is still reading this don't expect anything great I'm not a professional book reviewer. So to start off, this is a pretty interesting concept. Fairly original, and carves out it's own place in the reincarnation genre's inanimate object corner. The story "itself" is also well thought out. however the protrayel of the story isn't the "greatest". let me tell what I mean by that... The writer has this habit of telling and not showing. For the people who are not aware of what that means, I will describe it in a different way. When painting or drawing a picture for someone to see you usually flesh the image out give the picture depth and meaning in every stroke of the brush. I do not mean literally, like every square centimetre of paint has some kind of mystical meaning. It has meaning in the terms of portraying the depth of a video whilst it still being a still image. For example: shading, perspective, minute detail like pores on the skin or individual leaves on a tree. It gives the picture life. There is quite a bit of similarity between a painting and a book, in that they both try to describe a living scene, an entire world, on a still canvas. I'm sorry if my description still didn't help.😔 The point is the there is visible depth when you show, which isn't an effect you get when you tell. Telling is literally encapsulating the entirety of the scene in a couple of descriptive, but limited words. To show, is to describe the nuances of the scene, give the skeleton of the story flesh, describe what the author themselves see, to paint the picture in the readers' mind. As a writer you don't have to do this too often, you actually shouldn't. It's a device used when trying to really bring to life an important scene. However there is a difference between just right and too little. The entirety of that block of probably unnecessary text is me just saying the author's writing itself lacks depth. Not the story, just the writing. I think this is my last point. This is just my opinion on this one but, I feel like there is too much info dump, or the info dump is just not spaced out well enough, or the info dump just doesn't have any life. The last one might be on purpose seeing as it is just the characters grinding skills. Either way the writing isn't particularly well paced when around 60%(Not an exact meausrement) of 4+ chapters (Also not an exact measurement) straight is dedicated to an info dump. 🤔 But again this easily remedied if you just give the info dump more meaning and life, I think... 🤨 But who Am I to judge, I could just be spouting nonsense... Which makes this an immense waste of a morning that could have been spent watching Gawr Gura read Konosuba. Ah whatever, I enjoy the world the Author is trying to portray and I hope they continue to evolve the writing and the story.

This novel is so funny, it helps my mood when I read it and is a nice break from the more serious stuff I read?

Originally I was interested in the story due to the variety of skills and their potential, but the author got lazy with that pretty quickly. Though the other forms of gaining strength attract my intrust, I can't help but notice that I've stoped reading most of the bs and jumping ahead. (BS = long and boring side stories that are written in low quality)

Was going to say Webnovel should make it a comic but realized sticks wont really convert well into one

‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎ ‎

No Romance No like >:v No contenido +18 no like, no chicas lindas no like capishi ಠಿ⁠ヮ⁠ಠ realmente no entiendo como a gente Le gusta novelas tan largas pero no hay ningún tipo de romance o algo de limón para hacer que la historia tenga alma. Aunque no digo que pongan en cada capítulo eso almenos se necesita no?

Mc so beta, bored af. Lot of nonsense and stupid decision from MC, frustating

I just came to write or complain that 3\4 of the book or more doesn't even have the MC in it just switched to another character for more than 150 chapters. Just my opinion but you would expect to see the MC of the story more often.

The story is acceptable, except the part where the author spends 22 chapters describing a battle against lightning. That was annoying and boring. I don't recommend this novel to anyone, because it has been most probably abandoned. The author did not finish any of the previous novels they wrote, and it seems that this one will suffer the same destiny.

bit.ly/3LyRF1N 💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗💗

It cool and funny unexpected plot were the mc is a stick a powerful stick! So its good and I would like to recommend it to all the people who would like to see this kind of novel

I am currently reading chap 423, the novel start off very good. The concept does seen interesting, occasional typo can be put off and language is understandable However, eventhough world background scale is created to be gigantic, the character development and realism in choices have rooms for improvement. Story can certainly be easily predicted with readers where this isn't their first novel. Overall, it can be read in your free time but not heavily invest in it is a good choice

bro, thus stuff is amazing and so many other people should read it. Sincerely I wish you luck in future endeavors. I wish the everyone find a boon like this one.

The story started well, had some world background, mc making though not the best but just somewhat reasonable choices(like not focusing on skills and focusing on leveling up) but it can be somewhat ignored. So it continues like that for a while until the part where he evolves into a spiritas. I don't know how a character can change so drastically. I have read some really horrible books but even they don't have such a drastic change in character in a single chapter. One moment he is a somewhat intelligent stick and then next moment he is a stuttering idiot who (it is then mentioned that he is a 16 y old virgin) loses the ability to think and reveals every bit of his secrets to someone he just met (just because he thinks that they are 'compatriots' and totally were not forcing him a moment ago). Tells them that he is getting skills knowing fully well that it will be tough to explain how he knows the details and yet revealing it very easily, as easy as breathing. (Why do you want to go to the ruin ? Oh, nothing much. Just want to get some op skills that I can keep to myself for some advantage but now I telling you this because you are my friend and don't ask why I know,not telling you ). And when asked about is he is blessed by a god, he easily reveals it and even goes on to tell his story pretty eagerly and with great details(since they are compatriots of course). He reveals to a stranger he met some time ago about secrets one would take it to their graves, like being a human and getting reincarnated. Anyway, if it wasn't enough to leave a bad taste we have a mc who gets flustered by imaginging stick on stick when Herelia or something mentions something and behaves just how I imagine a 16y old would be and then we learn that he is a 16y old virgin. See, I have no problem with any kind of stick and personally love it but was it really needed to make the mc be a 16 y old virgin just for the sake of having a reason to be flustered?. From the start of the story I was expecting the mc to be 21 or older guy since he was behaving in a somewhat rational way?. Anyway, I think this is my second time reading it. The first time I read this was a long ago. It was these few chapters where he met Herelia that bothered me so much with the drastic character changes that I dropped it. And after so long I tried it again, I really wanted to give it a chance, read from the beginning..I really tried. But this part again made it so much unbearable for me to continue even a sentence. I really felt my brain throb and stop with every word I read( mostly how easily he revealed everything to a stranger where he could answer with a yes). I love books. When you invest so much feelings and time into something and get smacked straight on your face with something illogical and irrational, it really makes you doubt your life for a second. The author seems nice enough to take criticism in a good way, so I hope they improve because we really need some good writers. Every story I read leaves me with so much disappointment and unmet expectations, it is heartbreaking

Tambahkan ulasan Kualitas menulis Memperbarui Stabilitas Pengembangan Cerita Desain karakter latar belakang dunia Tarif Keseluruhan 5.0 Ulasan harus lebih dari 140 karakter

interesting never thought someone would come up the idea of being reborn as a stick that it sounds hilarious! anyway i'm definitely reading this

a few cliche here and there but overall pretty solid and unique novel, reason im raiting 4/5 is because currently the update stability is a fat 0/5. maybe the author has stuff going on and cant write often, so maybe it will get back to normal eventually.

Love the story so far, thanks.[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

Overall a solid story with alot of funny parts and some dad jokes included. Start might be a little slow but I like that about it. Hope to see alot more chapters

Just a bit of fun, Well written and refreshing change of pace. Yeah it’s silly but what did you expect from someone In an mmo where You play as a stick .

great story, great charater, well I'm not an expert but I'm having fun reading it. mad props for the author[img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

I give this a 2.5/5. Its a mediocre story with good ideas, poorly implemented. It also suffers from SAO syndrome meaning cool world design but a horrible game to actually play. The stick idea is a really interesting one and does have some good jokes and gags, but after a while it gets stale. The MC also spends way to long in that form. I mean it's called " Reincarnated As A Stick" not "My Life As A Stick". I kept hoping that what would come next, would change things up for the better, but eventually my interest was worn out.

This seems like a really interesting concept. I hope that the main character of this webnovel gets stronger a little faster, unlike other webnovels. This webnovel is really good. Thanks

[img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=update][img=update][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend][img=recommend]

👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍👍

Don't recommend reading it if you want to stay sane... If you want to have any desire to read at all start after chapter 6 at least. There will be less 4 wall breaking, and you don't miss anything, but save you mind from author stupidity and bad humour...

well I can't say to much but this is a very interesting concept and decent enough writing I also like how people want to use him as a weapon Material.