Reviews of Genshin Impact: Reborn Engineer by Forestkeeper - Webnovel

11Reviews

4.84

  • Writing Quality
  • Stability of Updates
  • Story Development
  • Character Design
  • World Background

Share your thoughts with others

Write a review
SR_2027

Writing Quality:5/5 Better than most fanfic. You can find some here and there, but not any major ones. === Updating Stability: 5/5 Seems like it’s updated fairly. === Story development: 4/5 I liked the story and how it was developed but some things just felt forced. I also felt like MC was just a bit too careless and naive. He go on with things that he know that could harm him, where in fact he could have just waited patiently for something else and worked over it. (That Vacher situation where he noticed Vacher staring at his companion but still didn’t plan on what could happen later on with that) This makes the plot feel a bit too forced. There is also a golden rule of reincarnation that was violated: never tell anyone that you’re reincarnated. It takes away the magic of the story. Character will just feel existential crisis; and instead of that, he could have just said he had prophetic abilities which were going weaker over time. == Character design: 5/5 I’m actually very amazed by how well done this fanfic represented many characters! It used that emotional impact too much with that abandoned child story but it is still better than most story. === World background: 5/5 Genshin impact world, specially Fontaine have some of the best world backgrounds that I’ve ever seen or read about. Top tier story with great characters. ===•=== Overall thoughts: 4.8/5 It’s a great story with great potential if done properly. Right now it seems to be on an critical level as the latest chapters felt a bit boring with too much of an focus on slice of life and character focused story development. It’s not bad to have great character development, but it’s also important to maintain story progression. In the last chapters I felt like dropping it because it somehow felt too boring… Would recommend working something on the latest chapters and future chapters!

img
4d
View 0 Replies
Resident_5326

Another diamond in the rough how beautiful I should've found you sooner...................................................................................................................

7d
View 0 Replies
Antonio_Herrero

:)............................................................................................................................................................(:

19d
View 0 Replies
Silver_174

Really like this one, we don’t have a lot of good genshin ff of this quality in here. The story is quite good with entertaining characters and plots, hope that you don’t give up on it.

1mth
View 1 Replies
JustoTR

Está bueno .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

Reveal Spoiler
2mth
View 0 Replies
Veldaza

yo author, in your reading list add the mangaka system it may be dropped but it's literally the perfect genshin fic

2mth
View 0 Replies
Muma_Chau

Honestly it's one of the better Isekai fics out their, the MC actually has to work to become overpowered, he actually tells a close friend that he's been reincarnated, and the plot is actually interesting and funny.

6mth
View 0 Replies
Sparow787

Peak writing definitely recommend reading this. Story is good and the characters are entertaining to read about, has potential to be one of the better fics I've seen on this app.

6mth
View 0 Replies
elpepe

Está bueno el fic, espero con ansias que sigas con el...........................................................................................................................

img
7mth
View 1 Replies
idk_what123

Deffinetly deserves more love. Though the Mc does have trust issues at first I like the relationship with their parent figure is going.

8mth
View 0 Replies
Imperators_Slave

Another diamond tier FF that added in my list of favorite FF

8mth
View 11 Replies
SR_2027

Writing Quality:5/5 Better than most fanfic. You can find some here and there, but not any major ones. === Updating Stability: 5/5 Seems like it’s updated fairly. === Story development: 4/5 I liked the story and how it was developed but some things just felt forced. I also felt like MC was just a bit too careless and naive. He go on with things that he know that could harm him, where in fact he could have just waited patiently for something else and worked over it. (That Vacher situation where he noticed Vacher staring at his companion but still didn’t plan on what could happen later on with that) This makes the plot feel a bit too forced. There is also a golden rule of reincarnation that was violated: never tell anyone that you’re reincarnated. It takes away the magic of the story. Character will just feel existential crisis; and instead of that, he could have just said he had prophetic abilities which were going weaker over time. == Character design: 5/5 I’m actually very amazed by how well done this fanfic represented many characters! It used that emotional impact too much with that abandoned child story but it is still better than most story. === World background: 5/5 Genshin impact world, specially Fontaine have some of the best world backgrounds that I’ve ever seen or read about. Top tier story with great characters. ===•=== Overall thoughts: 4.8/5 It’s a great story with great potential if done properly. Right now it seems to be on an critical level as the latest chapters felt a bit boring with too much of an focus on slice of life and character focused story development. It’s not bad to have great character development, but it’s also important to maintain story progression. In the last chapters I felt like dropping it because it somehow felt too boring… Would recommend working something on the latest chapters and future chapters!

img
4d
View 0 Replies
Resident_5326

Another diamond in the rough how beautiful I should've found you sooner...................................................................................................................

7d
View 0 Replies
Antonio_Herrero

:)............................................................................................................................................................(:

19d
View 0 Replies
Silver_174

Really like this one, we don’t have a lot of good genshin ff of this quality in here. The story is quite good with entertaining characters and plots, hope that you don’t give up on it.

1mth
View 1 Replies
JustoTR

Está bueno .......................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................................

Reveal Spoiler
2mth
View 0 Replies
Veldaza

yo author, in your reading list add the mangaka system it may be dropped but it's literally the perfect genshin fic

2mth
View 0 Replies
Muma_Chau

Honestly it's one of the better Isekai fics out their, the MC actually has to work to become overpowered, he actually tells a close friend that he's been reincarnated, and the plot is actually interesting and funny.

6mth
View 0 Replies
Sparow787

Peak writing definitely recommend reading this. Story is good and the characters are entertaining to read about, has potential to be one of the better fics I've seen on this app.

6mth
View 0 Replies
elpepe

Está bueno el fic, espero con ansias que sigas con el...........................................................................................................................

img
7mth
View 1 Replies
idk_what123

Deffinetly deserves more love. Though the Mc does have trust issues at first I like the relationship with their parent figure is going.

8mth
View 0 Replies
Imperators_Slave

Another diamond tier FF that added in my list of favorite FF

8mth
View 11 Replies