/ History / Isekai With The Job 'Modern Soldier'
2.68 (10 değerlendirmeler)
Özet
Johan Anderson, a high school teenager in Japan, along with his classmates, is suddenly summoned to another world by an empire that needs a hero to win the war. Each student gets a job that determines their abilities, but Johan gets a job that seems strange and useless: 'Modern Soldier'.
Etiketler
Bunlar da Hoşunuza Gidebilir
2.68
Düşüncelerinizi başkalarıyla paylaşın
Bir değerlendirme yazRead up to Chapter 18. The positives. - Writing Quality: There are almost no grammatical mistakes, which I guess is worth praising. - Updating Stabilty: This is probably fine? Idk tho, I don't really consider this to be important. Like a few others, I found a few flaws within the book, which I shall name now. (First, I'll write the critics, then I shall give examples of said things happening. The latter DOES contain spoilers, so be wary of that.) 1) Story is too rushed, and there's quite a bit of development missing. 2) Many of the MC's actions and worries don't make sense. I get that he's been transmigrated, but that shouldn't magically erase someone's ability to *think*, and analyze situations. 3) Author straight up ignores a lot of opportunities for character development/world-building, and even "skips" over showing a lot of important things. Examples of each instance mentioned (There ARE spoilers from here on). 1) We don't know a thing about the setting. The focus is almost exclusively on Johan, the MC. We, the readers (and probably even the Author), haven't seen many interactions not involving Johan. We haven't seen how Magic works, in spite of having quite a few of Johan's (mostly unnamed, because they get zero development) classmates who have some aptitude for wielding magic. 2) At first, he's shown to not trust the royal family a bit (he did have a fair reason), but not too long after, he trusts an outlier of said family enough to RUN AWAY with him and some of his classmates (the same ones who, less than 2 months ago, were telling him to off himself. Granted, the 3 classmates didnt participate *actively* in the bullying, but really? Where is the lack of the MC's trust in this entire sequence of events?) also the outlier somehow sounds as an amazing manipulator, better than the family. 3) We had a lot of scenarios like this. It's mostly Johan pulling a life-saving item, without us knowing WHEN he got the points for it. "oh, he was in the dungeon for a week, and he fought a Drake. That's where he got the 12.000 points from" That's just telling, and is another wasted chance at developing the Deus (ex) Machina system. Plus, what kind of quests did he get in order to obtain 12.000 points? The rifle and military clothes used to show off in the hall (and somehow no one having a *single smart thought*, because everyone conveniently forgets about it), the SCAR-something he pulled out against the Drake battle, the recording device he pulled out to record Princess Roselia's conversation (another event that the author did not mention at all, only bringing it up during a conversation with the Crown Prince. I'm sure overhearing THAT talk would have been something good, but alas... nothing), and the many explosive devices he had to give out to his friends. Yeah, that's about it. I'd suggest deleting the book and starting all over again, but it is contracted, so that solution is not usable (since contracted books can't be deleted). PS: got about 3000 letters with this review...
Spoileri GösterWhile i usually dont curse this much while reading this novel it had me cursing like a sailor if it's author's first novel i want to respectfully mention to step up your game if not then please just read your own works once, twice, maybe thrice before uploading
So many plot holes, the mc is a wimp, and lacks almost any intelligence. Bro had a rifle fighting in a dungeon and was only using a knife. When his whole job is fighting with guns, then when his teammates get beat up by a drake he’s like “ what do I do?” Use the gun. The author is just really bad at writing .
this is so bad with how it is written. The idea is good, but how the author does not know how to write a story
Unfortunately, I can't recommend this story. It has wasted so much of my time with filler content. The dialogue, plot, conflicts, and even character development are all uninteresting. I read this because it had a nice story idea, but that was all it had. A nice idea. In reality the story was boring, character's personalities are unknown even to the author, so much so that they are inconsistent, character backgrounds are the same here as well, so don't have high expectations for that either. The world is extreemly generic and boring. This looks like it was made in ChatGPT.
Hey there! I really enjoyed reading your work, every scene felt so vivid, like I could already see the panels forming in my mind. Your writing has that cinematic touch that would translate beautifully into a comic. I do paid commission-based comic work, and I’d love to explore what a visual version of your story might look like. You can always reach me on Discord (ava_crafts) or Insta (@eve_verse_) if you’d like to chat.
I just finished catching up, and wow, your storytelling is incredibly vivid. The pacing, the way emotions are described, and the detail in every scene made it feel like I was watching it unfold rather than just reading. The characters have such distinct personalities, and the world-building is so clear that I could easily imagine it as a webtoon or graphic novel. Honestly, the visual energy in your writing makes it perfect for that kind of adaptation. I’d absolutely love to see this story brought to life through art someday!
Yazar Hendra_Gunawan_2258
overall its good 👍, just one problem...... its too JAPANESE!!mawgawd the mc is so trusting,he behaves the average Japanese mc too spineless,too soft ,believes in the power of friendship...... OK I'm done ranting. but I do recommend this