What were the flaws in the Four Great Masterpieces and the Chinese classical novels?

2025-03-08 19:55

A blow-up referred to the fact that some plot or details in the novel did not conform to historical facts or that there were mistakes or contradictions in the details. The following are some of the flaws in the Four Great Masterpieces and Chinese classical novels: Dream of the Red Chamber: Dream of the Red Chamber is a classic Chinese classical novel. However, the actual situation of the Jia family and the feudal society depicted in the novel does not match the history. For example, the novel described Baoyu's birthday, but in history, Baoyu's birthday was on the 15th day of the first lunar month instead of the 20th day of the third lunar month. 2. Journey to the West: There are many plots in Journey to the West that do not conform to the historical background. For example, Sun Wukong once used the Jingu Bang on his way to obtain the scriptures. However, in history, the Jingu Bang was given to Tang Sanzang by the Dragon King. In addition, there are some plots in the novel that do not conform to Buddhist beliefs. For example, Tang Sanzang is described as a kind monk, but in history, Tang Sanzang was a famous monk in the Tang Dynasty who shaved his head and became a monk instead of a kind monk. 3. Water Margins: There are many plots in Water Margins that do not conform to the historical background. For example, the heroes of Liangshan Lake described in the novel used to be 108, but in history, the number of heroes of Liangshan Lake should be around 105. In addition, there are some plots in the novel that do not conform to Taoist beliefs. For example, Lin Chong is described as an immortal in the novel, but in history, Lin Chong was a general of the Song Dynasty instead of an immortal. Romance of the Three Kingdoms: There are many plots in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms that do not conform to the historical background. For example, Cao Cao is described in the novel as a smart and confused character. However, in history, Cao Cao was a famous politician and military strategist. His intelligence and wisdom were widely praised by later generations. In addition, there are some plots in the novel that do not conform to Buddhist beliefs. For example, Zhuge Liang described in the novel is an immortal, but in history, Zhuge Liang was a famous politician and military strategist, but he was not an immortal.