Two novels with similar outlines were written by the same author. Was that considered plagiarism?

Writing novels in the same format was not considered plagiarism. plagiarism refers to the act of directly or indirectly copying other people's works, thoughts, opinions, and creativity without authorization, which is a legal violation. The format of a novel could be fixed or flexible. As long as the author had a breakthrough and innovation in creativity and conception, it would not constitute plagiarism. In addition, if the format of the novel was similar to other works, but the plot, characters, background, and other elements had unique personalities and characteristics, it could still be regarded as a manifestation of innovation and uniqueness. Therefore, writing novels in the same format did not necessarily mean plagiarism. The key was whether there was a breakthrough and innovation in creativity and conception.

I'm sorry, but you didn't provide any information about the two novels. If you can provide the title of the novel or more context information, I can try to help you determine whether these two novels are plagiarized.

A novel with the same name was not necessarily plagiarized because plagiarism usually referred to the plot, characters, locations, and other elements of the work being similar or even directly copying the content of another person's work. And the fact that the names of the novels were not the same could be due to the author's reference or influence from other works. The legal definition of plagiarism was " the act of copying, distributing, renting, exhibiting, performing, screening, broadcasting, and information network transmission without the permission of the copyright owner." If the novel has the same name but is not similar and does not copy the content of another person's work, it may not be considered plagiarism. However, if the title of the novel was similar or even directly copied from someone else's work, it might be considered plagiarism. Therefore, authors should try to avoid plagiarism and respect the original when writing novels to avoid unnecessary trouble for the copyright owner.

The same setting of the novel could not be considered plagiarism because the setting of the novel itself was not original in the legal sense. The setting of a novel was usually some plot, scene, or character setting that the author randomly thought of during the creation process. They were not independent or innovative. However, if the background of two novels was similar, but there were big differences in the storyline, character personality, plot development, etc., there might be plagiarism. This was because the author might use similar plots, scenes, or character settings for multiple works according to their own imagination and ideas, resulting in plagiarism. Therefore, if the settings of two novels were the same but there were large differences in the storyline, character personality, plot development, and so on, there might be plagiarism. However, in this case, a concrete analysis was needed. They could not simply use the same setting as the standard for plagiarism.

Fictional plagiarism referred to the process of directly copying or borrowing other people's works, plots, characters, locations, etc. in the process of writing a novel and using them in one's own work. This kind of behavior not only violated copyright law but also damaged the intellectual property rights of the original author and negatively affected the reader's reading experience. Whether plagiarism was considered plagiarism required a detailed analysis of the situation. If you plagiarized someone else's creativity, ideas, or character settings, or simply quoted a scene or plot without directly copying or borrowing someone else's work, then it was not plagiarism. However, if the plagiarism was an important part of the entire work, such as characters, plot, theme, etc., and was directly used in the work, then this behavior was considered plagiarism. The plagiarism of novels was a serious form of copyright violation that needed to be avoided. When writing a novel, one should respect the rights of the original author and avoid plagiarism as much as possible.

There were different opinions on whether a novel with the same name and similar content as multiple novels could be considered plagiarism. In law, plagiarism referred to the act of creating or publishing a work with the same or similar text, structure, plot, or theme without the consent of the original author. If one novel had the same name as another and the content was similar to multiple novels, there might be plagiarism. However, there were many factors to consider whether it was plagiarism. 1. Whether the content of the work is the same or similar, and whether it is original; 2. Whether the creation method, time and place of the works are the same or similar, and whether they are original; 3. Whether the source of creation of the works is the same or similar, whether it is original; 4. Whether the work violates the intellectual property or other rights of the original author. If a novel had obvious similarities with another novel in terms of content, form, source, etc., and was confirmed by the original author, it might be considered plagiarism. However, the specific situation needed to be judged according to the specific situation. At the same time, the online literature industry had different views on the definition of plagiarism. Some readers believed that as long as the content of the work was similar, it should not be regarded as plagiarism, while others believed that as long as the content of the work was similar, it must be plagiarized. Therefore, whether a novel with the same name and similar content as multiple novels was considered plagiarism needed to be judged according to the specific situation.

"The Substitute King of the Three Kingdoms" is a historical novel written by 1,000 authors. The general plot of this novel is as follows: Cao Cao: Liu Bei, can you have some green lotus? Yuan Shao: Liu Bei, if you poach people from my place again, I'll be angry with you! Yuan Shu: Liu Bei, I wish I could eat your skin and sleep with your bones! [Lu Bu: Boss, I admit defeat. Can we stop fighting?] [Liu Bei: Lu Bu is already invincible. Why should I attack him?] ---------------------------- " Invincibility Begins from the Summoning of Fierce Generals in the Three Kingdoms " was a historical fiction novel written by the author, Dream Trash. The general plot of this novel was: 'I've transmigrated to become the most useless emperor, and I'm also someone else's puppet. But so what? I can summon a fierce general. I'll summon Zhang Fei first and let them know how powerful I am...' ---------------------------- Possessing Xuande was a historical novel written by the author, Drunken Wind and Clouds. The general plot of this novel was: A story of a soldier who had been discharged from military service and had traveled through time and space to possess Liu Bei. He wrote about Liu Bei not because he liked Liu Bei, but because of his Five Tigers, Dragon and Phoenix, Xu Shu, and so on. He regretted that Shu Han had so many powerful people and could not unify China. ---------------------------- " Summoning: The Battle of the Three Kingdoms " was a historical novel written by the author, Heavenly Tiger Wolf. The general plot of this novel was: At the end of the Eastern Han Dynasty, the heroes rose up together. Liu Qing brought the summoning system and descended into this era. The elites of all eras met here. What kind of sparks would be created when Liu Qing, who had been schemed against from the beginning, and what kind of broad road he could walk out of, everything was in the Summoning Chaotic Battle of the Three Kingdoms. ---------------------------- " Summoning of the Three Kingdoms in Troubled Times " was a historical novel written by the author, Crazy Is Me, and the Qin and Han Dynasties. The general plot of this novel was: " Think about how China has a history of 5,000 years. How many heroes have there been, and how many wonderful moments in history have been praised by the world? Then why can't we connect these fragments and form a new Three Kingdoms? Perhaps, the Three Heroes of Hulao Pass fighting against Lu Bu, Zhang Fei angrily shouting at Changbanqiao, Xu Chu naked warhorse Chao, Zhao Zilong sacrificing his life to save Adou, Cao Mengde defeated and fled to Huarong Road, etc. are enough exciting, but Li Yuanba has fallen to Siming Mountain, the seven heroes of Luoyang City have created lanterns, and Lu Tixia has punched Zhenguan West. Xu Ning defeated the Iron Chain Chain Horse, Li Cunxiao defeated Chang 'an with eighteen riders, the Heavenly King of Wu Dao, Ran Min, issued the order to kill the Hu, Mu Guiying defeated the Heavenly Gate Formation, Luo Tong swept the North, Qin Ying conquered the West, and others were not inferior. The Overlord of the Western Chu State broke his cauldrons and burned his boats, the King of Yue, Gou Jian, endured hardships and tasted courage, and Han Xin, the Immortal of Soldiers, could even endure the humiliation of his hips. When all of this was integrated into the Three Kingdoms? What kind of world would it form? ---------------------------- " The Hot-blooded Three Kingdoms: Summoning the Fierce Generals " was a historical novel written by Wenren Yebai. The general plot of this novel was: Possesses the deposed emperor Liu Bian, controls the summoning system. Liu Bei has Guan Yu and Zhang Fei, I have Qin Qiong and Li Cunxiao! Thousands of years of famous generals gathered together to create a grand empire! New book, The Strongest Dominator of the Three Kingdoms, seeking support! ---------------------------- " I, Liu Bei, Unlimited Summoning to Revive the Han Dynasty " was a historical fiction novel written by the author, Senior Ruyan. The general plot of this novel was: After being reborn and transmigrated to the Eastern Han Dynasty, I actually became Liu Bei, who ruled Xuzhou? It doesn't matter, I have the war support system. Billions of soldiers are at my beck and call, and the world is in my pocket! In this life, Liu Xuande would use Xu Prefecture as a base to dominate the world. He would no longer have to wander about! In this life, the Han Dynasty would rise again! Cao Cao: The heroes of the world are only me and Liu Bei. I didn't expect that a joke from before would actually come true! Xun Yu said,"I was blind. I thought that Liu Bei could only dominate one side. In fact, he was the hero who revived the Han Dynasty!" Sima Yi said,"I have no enmity with Liu Bei. Why did he target me so many times?" Zhuge Liang said,"I came out of the thatched cottage with the intention of bringing my lord away. I didn't expect my lord to be a king!" ---------------------------- " The Endless Summoning of the Three Kingdoms " was a historical novel written by the author, Tang Yan Gui. The general plot of this novel was: He had transmigrated into Tao Shang, the eldest son of Tao Qian. At this time, his cheap father had died and Xuzhou was occupied by Liu Bei. He had no reputation, no territory, and no people. He was in a difficult situation. I have the Heroic Soul Summoning System. I can summon famous generals and strategists from the previous dynasty for my use. If you have Lu Bu, you will be invincible. I will summon the Overlord Xiang Yu to compete. If you have Zhuge Liang, I will summon Zhang Liang for you and see whose wisdom is better. Ren Tu Bai Qi, Fei General Li Guang, War Saint Sun Wu…All the famous generals of each generation will be under my command. Let's see how the nameless trash will rise up against the heavens and lead the heroes of the past to suppress the three countries and achieve legendary hegemony... ---------------------------- " Summoning the Fierce Generals of the Three Kingdoms " was a historical novel written by the author, Bronze Swordsman. The general plot of this novel was: Guan Yu versus Qin Qiong, I think it's fine! He transmigrated to the deposed Young Emperor of Han, Liu Bian, and began the difficult journey of the Three Kingdoms. No territory, no soldiers, no talents, so what? I have the Super Summoning System, and the historical generals are at my beck and call! Don't mention Tiger Cage Pass Three Heroes versus Lu Bu. I'll summon a super combination of Heavenly King Wu Dao + Li Cunxiao + Li Yuanba. Can they fight? If you want to send the Five Tiger Generals and Five Good Generals, I will use a big move and summon a monkey to turn you into dregs in minutes! What? Mythical characters couldn't be summoned? Then just you wait. I'll go and see what the manual says first… Thousands of years of heroes and fierce generals in history gathered together to compete on the battlefield. Who was the hero in the world? The winner takes all, the loser takes all, the land is split and the marquis is granted. The strongest of the strong, the king of the kings, all depend on the fierce generals summoned by the Three Kingdoms! ---------------------------- Summoning the Divine Martial Arts of the Three Kingdoms, I am the Supreme One, was a fantasy novel written by the author, Yijun Yishui. The general plot of this novel was: This was a world where martial arts were revered. Some successful adepts established powerful countries or sects and dominated a region. A person from Earth, with the mythical version of the Three Kingdoms Celebrity Summoning System, summoned some civil officials and generals from the late Eastern Han or the Three Kingdoms period for his own use. Zhuge Liang, the Sleeping Dragon, Guo Jia, the God of War, Lu Bu, Zhao Zilong, Zhao Yun, one of the four beauties of ancient times, Diao Chan, Goddess Luo Zhen Mi, the sisters of Jiangdong, Xiao Qiao, the three immortals of the late Han Dynasty, and Hua Tuo, the divine doctor… [Zhu Junzhu, a transmigrator: The famous people of the Three Kingdoms are all under my control. Who can compete with me?]

The story background, character setting, plot, and other elements of the novel can be used for reference, but they cannot be completely similar or identical, because this will not only bring readers reading difficulties, but also not in line with the original intention of the novel creation. If a novel's background, character setting, plot, and other elements were completely similar, or even if there was only one plot that was the same, it could be considered plagiarism. plagiarism refers to the act of borrowing elements or plots from other works and using them in one's own work without authorization. In order to avoid plagiarism, they should use different plots and backgrounds to show their own unique stories and styles. Also, avoid copying other people's works.

The definition of novel plagiarism usually refers to the author directly or skillfully applying other people's works, plots, characters, ideas, etc. to his own works without authorization, making them identical or very similar to the original works. Not only did plagiarism damage the intellectual property rights of the original work, but it also destroyed the market order and creative environment. It was a loss for both the original author and the readers. If there was plagiarism in the novel, the readers could defend their rights and interests through legal means, including copyright protection and litigation against the plagiarized works. At the same time, the creative team should also strengthen the supervision of creation to avoid plagiarism and other bad creative behavior.

If the plot, character setting, or main outline of a web novel were similar to someone else's work or even completely copied someone else's work, it might be considered plagiarism. In web novels, plagiarism was a common way of writing because it could quickly gain a lot of inspiration and did not require too much effort. However, if plagiarized works were discovered, it might have a negative impact on the author's reputation and income. In order to avoid plagiarism, authors should always create their own plots and character settings. In addition, authors should also carefully review their works to avoid similarities or plagiarism.