Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel on the board. I can't find out the specific details and background information from the search results provided.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him with a flogging.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian by kneeling was that Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. " Fan Sizhe is indeed greedy," Fan Xian said." But have you thought about it?"

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel on the board. This incident happened in Joy of Life, which showed the complicated parent-child relationship and family disputes. The specific details and background information could not be obtained from the search results provided.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel on the board. This experience showed Fan Jian's suspicion and distrust of Fan Xian, which led to his punishment. Fan Xian defended his and his brother's innocence through debate and pleading for his brother. This incident was depicted in Joy of Life, showing the complicated parent-child relationship and family disputes.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. " Fan Sizhe is indeed greedy," Fan Xian said." But have you thought about the reason?" This experience showed Fan Jian's suspicion and distrust of Fan Xian, which led to his punishment. Fan Xian defended his and his brother's innocence through debate and pleading for his brother. The incident where Fan Jian punished Fan Xian by kneeling on the board was depicted in Joy of Life, showing the complicated parent-child relationship and family disputes.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. " Fan Sizhe is indeed greedy," Fan Xian said." But have you thought about it?"

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel on the board. This incident happened in " Celebrating Years ", which showed the complicated parent-child relationship and family disputes. The specific details and background information could not be obtained from the search results provided.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was that Fan Jian suspected Fan Sizhe of colluding with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel. This incident happened in " Celebrating Years ", a plot in the novel.

The reason Fan Jian punished Fan Xian with a flogging was because Fan Jian suspected that Fan Sizhe had colluded with the Crown Prince's people to conspire to kill Fan Xian. Fan Xian pleaded on behalf of his brother, and Fan Jian suspected that it was his wife Liu Ruyu's idea. Fan Xian also refuted it. Fan Xian asked his father to apologize to his brother because he had not done anything wrong. In the end, Fan Jian did not apologize to Fan Xian. Instead, he punished him by making him kneel on the board. This incident happened in Joy of Life, which showed the complicated parent-child relationship and family disputes. The specific details and background information could not be obtained from the search results provided.