Did Yan Bingyun stab Fan Xian in the novel?

The original novel Joy of Life did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian. This plot was adapted from the TV series Joy of Life. In the play, Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian was a plan the two of them had discussed beforehand. The goal was to let Yan Bingyun gain the trust of the Second Prince so that he could better be a spy. Thus, the original novel did not have the plot of Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian.

The novel Joy of Life did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. According to the information provided, the novel did not clearly describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian.

The novel " Celebrating Years " did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. Thus, in the novel, Yan Bingyun did not stab Fan Xian.

The novel Joy of Life did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series, probably to create suspense and arouse the audience's expectations. According to some views, Yan Bingyun might be the Second Prince's man and had been ordered to assassinate Fan Xian because Fan Xian had exposed the collusion between the Second Prince and the Eldest Princess, as well as the Northern Qi empress dowager's deal. In addition, there were also people who believed that Yan Bingyun had helped Fan Xian fake his death to protect himself so that he could successfully escape danger. In short, the novel did not clearly describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian.

The novel " Celebrating Years " did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. Therefore, according to the information provided, there was no plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian in the novel.

In the novel Joy of Life, there was no description of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. Thus, there was no plot in the novel where Yan Bingyun stabbed Fan Xian.

The novel Joy of Life did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. According to the analysis of the TV series, there were two possibilities for Yan Bingyun's assassination attempt on Fan Xian. One possibility was that Yan Bingyun was the Second Prince's man and had been ordered by the Second Prince to kill Fan Xian. In the play, Fan Xian found out the truth about the Second Prince and Eldest Princess colluding. In order to protect himself, the Second Prince sent people to threaten Fan Xian and kill him. In the process, Yan Bingyun assassinated Fan Xian. The other possibility was that Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun had conspired to fake his death so that Fan Xian could return to Jingdou smoothly. In short, there was no plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian in the novel.

Joy of Life's original novel did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian. This plot was adapted from the TV series Joy of Life. In the play, Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian was a plan the two of them had discussed beforehand. The goal was to let Yan Bingyun gain the trust of the Second Prince so that he could better be a spy. Therefore, in the novel, Yan Bingyun did not stab Fan Xian.

The novel Joy of Life did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. According to the analysis of the TV series, there were two possible reasons for Yan Bingyun's assassination of Fan Xian. The first possibility was for the stability of the Qing Kingdom and Fan Xian's escape. Fan Xian knew that the Second Prince would chase after him, so they had discussed this plan beforehand. They would let Yan Bingyun stab him so as to give him a chance to escape and let Yan Bingyun gain the Second Prince's trust. The second possibility was that Yan Bingyun was the Second Prince's man and had been ordered by the Second Prince to kill Fan Xian. In the movie, Fan Xian found out that the masterminds behind the palace treasury smuggling in Shangjing were the Second Prince and Li Yunrui. To protect himself, the Second Prince sent people to threaten and kill Fan Xian when he was about to return to the Qing Kingdom. Yan Bingyun stabbing Fan Xian to death had happened during this process. Yan Bingyun might be the Second Prince's man or have some leverage in the Second Prince's hands, so Yan Bingyun had no choice but to obey the Second Prince and kill Fan Xian.

The novel " Celebrating Years " did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian. This plot was added during the adaptation of the TV series to leave suspense and let the audience have some expectations for the next season. Therefore, according to the information provided, there was no plot in the novel where Yan Bingyun stabbed Fan Xian.

Yes, according to the information provided, in the novel Joy of Life, Fan Xian had indeed been stabbed by Yan Bingyun. However, Fan Xian did not truly die. Fan Xian and Yan Bingyun had discussed this plan beforehand. They wanted Yan Bingyun to stab him so that he would have a chance to escape and gain the Second Prince's trust. Thus, the plot of Fan Xian being stabbed by Yan Bingyun was added during the adaptation of the TV series. The purpose was to create suspense and arouse the audience's expectations. The original novel did not describe the plot of Yan Bingyun assassinating Fan Xian.