Carrottop - Profile

Carrottop

LV 1
2019-09-10 Joined Global

Badges 1

Moments 19

Carrottop
Posted

Amazing story! The only downside to the story for me PERSONALLY is how Naruto is portrayed. Don't get me wrong, I think the author did an amazing job recreating Naruto's personality. However, it went to the extreme in terms of how detached from reality and retarded Naruto's sense of justice is. Even in the anime Naruto killed people that were trying to kill him. But in this story, he is taking Batman's principles to the extreme! A bandit or ninja is massacring civilians and r*ping women left and right? That's OK, as long as they say they're sorry. They do it again after their "redemption" (aka Naruto gives them a spanking and puts them in timeout)? That OK as well as long as they pinky promise that they won't do it again. As some point the suspension of disbelief hits a limit. At this point, while I absolutely love the rest of the story, I DREAD any Naruto POV narration or any part of the story where he opens his mouth. Hell, I even hoped quite a few times that he gets killed off and the author adjusts the storyline without this insufferable parasite. Author, if you're reading this, for the love of god, please change Naruto's personality, at least progressively. Every time he opens his yap I debate whether this is the reason that Uzushiogakure was destroyed in the original story. If there was a village that has retarded people like this Naruto all around, then its perfectly reasonable for the village to get wiped out for the good of the world.

Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Posted

Author stole multiple fan fiction stories, including this one. Has already been reported and changed his account name from dark789, and even tried to create patreon for someone else’s work. Pathetic parasite.

This book has been deleted.
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Carrottop
Replied to Unknown_ID

Lol, I was honestly waiting for someone like you to add their unintelligible gibberish. What I provide is honest feedback with some pointers, not just like a pointless "yes man" that only knows how to write "great chapter" or "moooooore" for every review. I do appreciate the story and how it started, and I bothered to write this review because the authors on this site have a tendency to drop their fanfics because their story is no longer high enough on the ranking. This has happened to plenty of stories because people like you act like sheep and don't bother to provide the author with quality feedback. Do you think that only saying "great chapter!" and boosting an author's ego will help them? Nope. It just makes it harder for them to understand why their stories are dropping in popularity, which results in them rage quitting their work. Also, my dear ignorant troll, do you know why reviews that have longer descriptions have generally more readers? It's because those are the kind of reviews that potential readers look for to decide whether or not they should invest their time in reading something that may potentially be utter garbage, or, alternatively, a hidden gem. Keep that in mind before you decide to drop your uselessly protective reply under someone else's comment. Comments are there for the author to read or reply to, not you.

Carrottop
Commented

It looks like the MC's IQ and maturity as someone who is over 20 years old mentally is inversely proportional with his fighting skills....You can't justify the lack of forethought and mindboggling level of cringe/edginess in his thought process or speech just by saying that his pre**** body is affecting his mind or that being a pervert "runs in the family", the level at which this is being shown is unrealistic. I have personally never met anyone over 10 years old who has such an unrealistic view of the world or who hasn't grown out of their chunibyo syndrome at that age. He was born in that world, and yet he is LESS mature than the kids that were never reborn! Heck, if you told me that he has a mental disorder that is limiting him mentally somehow then it would make more sense than whatever dialogue is being shown here. This fanfic started off well enough, with an understandable thought process from the MC, and then as soon as the MC started training or got a girlfriend, it's like he devolved into a glorified primate with an overblown ego the size of Mt Everest. I was never a fan of Rudeus in the novel, but how it THAT clown, who was a former trash NEET with mental scars(if you can even call them that), more mature then someone who was supposedly at least a semi-functioning ***** before dying? Author, please, don't ruin this fanfic with subpar dialogue. A good rule of thumb is, if you can't imagine someone saying something in real life without hiding their face in utter shame, or you saying it in front of a crowd, then it probably shouldn't be written down, otherwise it will degrade your character.

Carrottop
Replied to Tokyoghost

I agree with you that it depends on the story. Depending on the story's setting and what power level the mc starts off with, then it can turn out to be an entertaining story, like Onepunch Man or even the Hulk, although some of his powers also get blown out of proportion. However, the story in this case gives the mc a pretty clear immortality power and progresses for the first couple of time skips spanning over 100 years as it being his only power. Now, all of a sudden, the mc gets op Phoenix powers because of "reasons"? That wouldn't be good storytelling, that is just the author running out of ideas to push the story forward and so he/she uses a spontaneous power-up of ridiculous proportions. It's one thing of using something like a super-soldier serum to give the mc a slight physical power boost, that MAY somehow synergize with his mutant genes, since they are both of the physical strength/healing/endurance type, and cause a stronger effect then with Captain America. But if the same serum somehow gives the mc the power to warp reality? At this point I call bullshit, as with many actual comic books. There has to be a logical explanation that is not too farfetched as to why/how the power up occurred. For example, if for the majority of the story the mc has fire powers, and then the author runs out of ideas on its various applications, they can't just say that the mc can now all of a sudden control time because of the following logical leaps--->fire powers means that mc can control the vibration rate or movement of atoms, which leads to them being able to stop their movement, which means that they now have ice powers, which means that they can somehow stop time cause they can stop the atoms from moving. That, my friends, is a MASSIVE leap in logic and it immediately shows the author's lack of creativity, as is unfortunately the case with many comic books.

Carrottop
Commented

I honestly prefer this version of the story. Way too many fanfictions on this site give their mc some op hyper diversified bullshit powers without the mc putting any work into it, which is just lazy writing. "Oh, not only do you have telekinesis, but also can summon Master Chief from Halo with all of the future tech as well using some bullshit setting of his soul reincarnating within your body? And you have a system that let's you magically get op because you went on a quest to kill 10 rats from your mom's basement? That's great and totally believable." Having the phoenix force would have made almost any confrontation with other powerful beings completely anti-climactic. "Oh, is that the Hulk and Thor rampaging? Let me just flick my wrist and they're dead." You might as well end the novel right then and there. The problem with many fictions on this site is that the mc goes from 0 to 100 in no time at all with almost no effort, character development, or struggle. Do you know why manga and anime like naruto was popular? It's cause there was gradual and relatable development in the story line. How ridiculous would it have been if naruto went from getting his ass kicked at the academy to fighting off pain within a few months? Author, if you're reading this, for the love of anime god, please don't do the same shit as everyone else on this site does. Keep it slow and believable, it is much better for the mc to use his long life, wealth, and experience to resolve problems using his cunning, and maybe some help from not too op telepathic powers, then him having apocalyptic/phoenix level of power that throws all of his previous development into the proverbial dumster. Great job so far!

Carrottop
Carrottop
Report user