HooliganReader - Profile

HooliganReader

LV 2
2022-08-27 Joined Global

Badges 3

Moments 17

HooliganReader
Replied to Chibi_Wolf38

This was exactly my reaction!

"If it's convenient, I would like to ask for your advice on how to make pastries."

She Is From The Countryside

She Is From The Countryside

General · Zi Xuan

HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
Replied to HooliganReader

Updated review I am back after the completion of this novel and I must admit it isn’t as bad as my initial first impression. I’m not saying what I initial reviewed wasn’t true, it’s just that the author managed to vastly improve in the later chapters (you’ll probably start realising it in the mid to late 200 chapters). It became like every other Mary Sue novels that I enjoyed. Based on my past review, this is my update on how the author resolved the crappiness: 1 / 2. Illogical Mary Sue-ness and unexplained backstory: wells towards the middle, the author does try to explain where she got her skills and knowledge from which resulted in her being set as a character with infinite part time jobs and someone who has access to numerous masters in their crafts. Though it’s not the most logical, at least that something to work with and beats the assassin/doctor/poison master combo hehehe. 3. Forced awkward banter between characters: The banter is GREATLY reduced! Like even if the author added the banter, it’s much shorter and not as stiff. So kudos to the author for the major improvement. 4. The romance is SHIT: Wells for this, I really can’t comment much on it. I think for all Mary Sue novels, the romance tends to be low-key crappy. Usually with the stiff cold guy doing stuff in the the background and the female lead shinning and faceslapping everyone. For this, at least the male lead has some sort of a personality and is not only cold and stiff so that’s great. He’s the type that can throw his image down for the female lead and is a total wife/ daughter slave . After the initial ekky-ness of his pursuit of the female lead is gone, it’s just those nonsense fluff and couple banter (which I personally don’t really enjoy that much anyways so it was ok). 5. The antagonists are SHIT: The brain dead sluts have been GREATLY reduced. Towards the later chapters, you’ll only see less than 3 or so for the few hundred chapters which is great! But then we have obnoxious egoistic politicians next, but it’s still acceptable because honestly I understand where they come from. And logically their decisions aren’t very hard to understand and they actually do have the people in mind in the initial decision making and they have to make the decision between a rock and a hard place (it’s like saving 1 person vs saving 1000 people thing, which is morally right?) however because it’s a Mary Sue novel, later on, the follow up decisions become crazier and crazier and so you’ll have a country building novel on your hand! Besides local politicians, you’ll also have egoistic foreign politicians. This one… the author just writes them as morally kidnapping greedy beasts soooo 6. The interstellar era is so backwards and the people are dumb: The author does try to explain why the medical technology isn’t up to par and it’s something about them not consuming actual food blablabla and some gene technology. The explanation was quite decent too. As for the dumb interstellar people, hmm… besides the dumb antagonists, there’s an addition of the dumb netizens . Like I get that the main characters are your much loved idols but….their response to the “greater benefit” is really lacklustre. I don’t know how to explain it but the common peoples views are just majorityly one sided and very very very bias towards the main couple (I don’t understand how they aren’t angry or hate the couple after what they have done ahem they incited civil war) but it’s a totally acceptable occurrence. 7. Ingredient plot hole: nothing to add to this. The phase of how hard it is to process the materials and all has passed. Also the female lead managed to find a way to detox the materials but it was never rally said how the other country who supplied it got to benefit. Just sayin… Overall, the plot progress was great. There were really many interesting plot developments which weren’t too abrupt and randomly added. It’s quite a fresh read. Think every other decent/ good Mary Sue novel but with a new background and unique-ish plot. I thought it would end round 400 chapters in and I was pleasantly surprised that it was going on for 700 chapters. There were quite a few time skips which I enjoyed too and everything was wrapped up nicely. There still are some criticisms I have though. For example, I don’t like how the author made the children twins yet completely neglected the male baby. Like the little girl is so sweet so kind so amazing and her future husband is a cold decisive wife slave but what about her brother. It was not mentioned whatsoever. It’s just that we know that he’s a little playful that’s all. It feels like the only reason the author added the little boy is so that she can show of the male and female lead’s awesomeness that they can produce two babies at once. Also, I didn’t expect that the story was just gonna end like that but I did enjoy the last part of the female lead’s biography and history though. Overall, recommend if you enjoy food novels, Mary Sue protagonist, wife slave male leads, country building, some bits of entertainment circle plot developments, military and political stuff, cute babies and pets, but only if you can hold on reading a crappy novel for 200 chapters. If you can do so, you’ll be pleasantly surprised by this novel.

HooliganReader
HooliganReader
Posted

I’m currently at chapter 153 and I have to say, what you expected at the beginning is what you get. And in case y’all haven’t experienced the beginning, all I can say that it’s CRAP. Though the story does improve a little further in, it still isn’t a very good read. The crappiness in the beginning is the MC being so naive and impulsive when some random dude egged her on, she just took a bet without knowing what she was getting into which erked almost every reader of the novel. I think from then on the preconceived judgement has been formed and so the critical side of me has been unleashed! The crappiness later on is as follows: 1. The Mary Sue-ness of the story. I’ve always been all for Mary Sues (I don’t really like it when my MC isn’t OP, so that’s saying something) but this MC, sigh I don’t even know what to say. She is simply lucky in every way and just randomly knows how to cook stuff (which leads to the next point). Her unfounded golden fingers/ abilities is what makes the Mary Sue-ness so unpleasant. It’s illogical and random. Her character is low-key white lotus-ey too. Everyone (who hold some semblance of power, mostly male) who sees her sees that she somewhat “different” and finds her “interesting” and I mean EVERYONE and the most ridiculous part is, even what she does is normal and seems like nothing much, they be like ooo my interest is piqued! BLUGGGEEHH! It’s because every other person you’ve met have brain holes!. It feels like a 13 year old writing a Wattpad story here URGHHHHH 2. There is no proper character build up and clear backstory. Most of the cultivation Mary Sue novels have some backstory where she’s an assassin/ doctor/ poison master/ special forces commander or for those interstellar/ modern day ones where the MC is probably a Film Empress or world renowned chef or something. But based on what I understand from the backstory (as of Chapter 153), she is either in her late teens or early to mid twenties in her previous world and her occupation is an orphan. That’s all we know about her. Which is so stupid because for some odd reason she knows how to cook all kinds of nonsense. Wells at least we have a reason for her childish temperament and kiddy retorts 3. The banters between characters are so stiff that it feels forced. What’s there to add. Whether it’s between “brothers”, between owner and pet or between leader and subordinate their interactions are so unnecessary and try hard at being funny/ witty. Think scripted interactions between two hosts. Also, the MC and side characters feel touched at the most ridiculously normal actions. BRAIN HOLES. 4. The romance is SHIT. I get that love at first sight is a thing for Mary Sue novels but this…he fell in love with her because he saw a calm light in her eyes when she was held hostage… the fudgeeeee? Then he became obsessed it was like he was possessed. The worst part is, he knows she’s a minor (I think by our age range she’s like 8 years old and he’s like 21 but at the same time since she’s “developed” it’s a grey area) and he’s super lustful and forceful towards her. At least she’s reacting in a normal way. I mean I’m usually ok with age gap (the not legal kind) and forced romance but I need a little something to work with a least. This….sigh 5. The antagonists are SHIT. They are (mostly) drop dead gorgeous sluts who are arrogant, entitled, self absorbed and lustful. I’m not dissing them, this is exactly how the author wrote them. They for some odd reason took a look at the MC and decided that she ain’t shit and needs to be put in her place. They’ll try to entice any handsome men around her and are faceslapped in a ridiculous way after they have lost in a childish banter with the MC. Absolutely RIDICULOUS! 6. The interstellar era is so backwards and the people are ridiculously dumb. Sigh, with their ridiculously futuristic technology, they couldn’t figure out the cause of gout? They can compress the necessary nutrients into a capsule but they can’t add some iodine in it?? As for the dumbness of the people Exhibit A: when cameras were rolling, these FAMOUS (like super duper famous) female celebrities can’t even pretend and just have bij fights and showed their ugly sides on camera. Like…? SIGH. EVERY one of the bij antagonist is just for the author to contrast how pure and elegant and cute (honestly can one even be elegant and cute at the same time) the MC is. BLUEGH! 7. Ingredients plot holes. The author even needed to find oil and salt for the MC. How the hell did sugar come about? Side note who the hell knows how to manually process oil? Apparently this MC with no background whatsoever. There are too many bad stuff about this novel I don’t even know why I’m continuing on. But on a positive note, the concept of the story is very very interesting and the overall flow of the story is quite decent. It’s just the characters, the romance, the interactions, the brain holes….S-FUDGING-IGH

img
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
HooliganReader
Posted

If you're expecting a faceslapping novel where the FL destroyes the original book heroine in like the first arc or something, counterattacks all the haters and proceeds to dominate the world and be a winner in life, you will be sorely dissapointed. This novel is literally about a girl living her life tryna avoid the original heroine but the cockroach-like-heroine just can't leave her be and keeps pestering her then playing the victim. Like hot damn that heroine is annoying. Add a large handful relationship development (this is one of those novels that actually carried out relationship development) and another cup of lovey dovey dog food, you'll have this novel. The story flow is actually pretty good and the writing and translation is decent too. The plot twist and the ending was my cup of tea, definitely 💯💯. However, the fact that the story revolved around the original heroine was too annoying for me. I understand that it's literally where this story comes from but URGH it got tiring real fast. Like the author could have just shorten the story to achieve the same goal but she dragged it on. Maybe it was because I was expecting it to flow in a different way (aka counterattacking everywhere and a winning in life plot type) which made the story increasingly hard to read. But I think if you went in with a different expectation, this story would have been a really good read. Overall, if you wanna try this novel, give it a go. It's quite a pleasant read (just bear with that annoying original heroine).

HooliganReader
Posted

Ok do not look at the rating because though I didn’t give full stars on some of the required items (because they really aren’t worth more than 3 tbh), the overall story is some quality read! Definitely a 4.5 star read (well I’m new to Webnovel so I’m using a NovelUpdates standard)! How to know a novel is great? When you keep hoping the extras never end and that is precisely what happened with this. Side note: read the raws 穿书八零成了五个大佬的后妈 for the extras that were not translated (a must read fir closure) I got into this just randomly looking for a counterattack novel with good business management and plot flow and boy of boy did it hit all the right buttons. It has: ✅ Faceslapping unreasonable relatives ✅ Poor to rich - business management ✅ Quality childcare (with 5 stepchildren how can it not) - genius children ✅ Rooomacceee (which I felt is one of the best romance I’ve read so far) So the entire plot is basically about this transmigrated woman who found herself in a viscous supporting role in a novel and decided to make do with what she had by becoming the nanny to her stepchildren who were tragic villains in the novel. The story revolves around her fighting for herself and the kids to get away from her toxic in-laws (after her husband’s death), making money to support the kids so that they could develop their talents and basically all about the children’s career and her business’s development (mainly on the children’s career though). As she takes care of the kids, she falls in love with them and they her (parent-child love people not the romantic thing). I don’t know if you’d consider this slice of life but to me it’s borderline with loads of plots in between. The romance … from the fact I wrote another para for it says a lot. It’s a real slow burn. At first I was just anxious like who the heck is the male lead. Like come on! I had Potential ML 1 popping up and I was SURE he was it then Potential ML 2 shows up and I was like ok maybe not this might be it though, then Potential ML 3 turned up and I was like this it it but then another ML got more screen time and I was CONFUSED! The author really had me guessing but in the end my ship did sail sooooo hehehe all is good! When they finally got together oh the dog food you’ll be feed hohohooooo. Oh and the FL did not string anyone along. She made it very clear with everyone from the start that she wasn’t looking for no romance. Character wise … the FL is a strong independent woman who is straight woman in romance so there was no lovey dovey until like more than halfway through. Her golden fingers consists of her knowledge (for some odd reason she seems to know tonnnns about general studying/knowledge stuff), business acumen i guess, her protagonist halo aka her unreasonably amazing luck and let’s not forget her ‘ox-like’ strength that has allowed her to muscle her way through a lot of problems. There are five kids aka Dong, Xi, Nan, Bei and Zhong (aka Xiao Wu - Little Five coz he’s the fifth kid) - East, West, South, North and Central/ Center (there actually a more common way to say it which is Dong, Nan, Xi, Bei so I totally got confused with Second and Third brother). Dong is the typical big bro, super responsible but taciturn because he has a stutter. His talent is in running businesses and having amazing business ideas which led to him being a business tycoon. Second Brother Xi (twin to Dong) is a gifted author who has a sharp tongue but a tofu heart. His talent is in writing may it be books or screenplay. In the end, he became a media mogul. Third Brother Nan is an evil critter. He has many scheming ideas that he discusses with his cunning Second Brother. His talent is in studying. You heard right STUDYING. Helps the type of genius that absorbs knowledge like sponge and absolutely loves it. From law knowledge to chemistry, you name it it knows it. His patented technology could earn him riches he could spend for a lifetime but he creates because he loves and because of his mother (aka our FL). Little Bei (twin to Nan) is the only little girl in the family and she is crowned the youngest movie queen. Versatile and lovely, she wins hearts all over despite her age. Finally, there is Xiao Wu, the little brother of the family. The musical genius who started composing since he was three and who could compose pieces that heal. Their journey of how they slowly grow up and discover their talents, and how the FL brings them out of their shell and heals their scars is what this novel is basically about so sweeetttt! There were also tons of hilarious moments that made me laugh out loud. Another thing I liked about the novel is that some of the canon fodder MLs also have their happy endings and also that the original novel’s male and female protagonist weren’t total crapheads who are inherently evil. Plot wise, a lot of the hidden/ mysterious factors were really obvious, either the author HEAVILY hinted or it was just darn easy to guess. But boy oh boy that TWIST that hit you later on HOT DAMN. It had me….not gonna spoiler it hehehe. I felt that the ending was great too! Loved ittttt! The plot and all was nice but because the novel focuses on raising the kids (and developing their careers) and building their worldviews, one con about this novel would be, the author/ characters’ skewed views. Like some of the theories and views they brought it could have been better discussed with a more neutral view but I felt that the character (especially the female lead) take a really strong stance in an annoyingly righteous way. So, that kinda annoyed me a little. Also, a bit of a spoiler here (but not really since the summary already gave it away), I don’t like how the author crap on the kids biological dad. Like, I understand that the FL was there when the kids needed her the most but … I don’t know how to say. The kids interaction with their dad was just a little meh. Their affection for him is like 5% of their affection towards their mom aka the FL. So, there’s that. But overall, it is still a good read! Definitely recommend to anyone considering!

HooliganReader
Report user