What are the problems with a 'Dumbledore Gets Harry Pregnant' fanfiction idea?

There may be such extremely non - canon and inappropriate fanfiction out there in the vastness of the internet, but it goes against the original nature and values of the Harry Potter series. J.K. Rowling's world has certain boundaries and this concept is far from what was intended in the original story.

One major problem is that it goes against the nature of the relationship between Sirius and Harry in the original 'Harry Potter' series. Their relationship is more of a mentor - mentee or a father - son like bond, not a romantic or sexual one.

Well, there are several issues. It's a complete distortion of the characters. Harry Potter is a character known for his heroic deeds and positive traits in the original series. Reducing him to such a vulgar concept is unacceptable. Also, it's not in line with the target audience of the Harry Potter franchise, which includes a large number of young readers. Moreover, it can create a negative image of the fan community if such inappropriate fanfics are allowed to exist.

Well, it's a rather strange concept. In the context of the Harry Potter world, Sirius is an important figure in Harry's life, providing support and guidance. The idea of this kind of relationship leading to pregnancy is not only against the norms of the original story but also goes against the moral and ethical framework that the series subtly implies. It's a very far - fetched and uncomfortable idea to consider.

In most official Harry Potter works, Dumbledore is a guiding and protective figure for Harry. However, in some fanfictions, authors might explore dark or alternative interpretations. But these are not based on the original intended relationship. Fanfiction often takes creative liberties, but it doesn't mean it reflects the real essence of the characters as J.K. Rowling created them.

The main problem is that it completely distorts the original characters. Naruto has his own set of relationships, goals, and a world that revolves around ninja and his friends in Konoha. Koneko has her own story in the High School DxD world with different rules about magic and the supernatural. Combining them in this way for this kind of plot is disrespectful to the original creators' intentions and the essence of the characters.

One problem could be that it might change the perception of the original characters in an unwanted way. Fans who love the original relationship between Ash and Lillie might not like this new, more adult - themed take.

Well, considering the diversity of fanfiction, it's possible. Fanfiction allows for a great deal of creative license. Writers can explore unusual relationships and scenarios. A plot like Harry getting pregnant by a basilisk would be a very odd and unexpected twist, but it could exist within the realm of fan - created stories. It might explore themes like magic gone wrong or some really strange magical consequences that lead to such an event.

Well, Harry would probably have a very different upbringing. He'd be surrounded by Dumbledore's wisdom all the time. He might learn magic at a much faster pace and gain deeper insights into the wizarding world's history and secrets right from the start. Dumbledore could also protect him more effectively from the dark forces, as he's one of the most powerful wizards. And Harry would grow up in an environment full of magic and knowledge, which would shape him into a different kind of wizard compared to the original story.

In a 'Harry Potter gets revenge on Dumbledore' fanfiction, Harry could find out that Dumbledore knew about certain threats to his life but didn't do enough to protect him. So, Harry decides to get revenge by undermining Dumbledore's influence at Hogwarts. He might start by convincing the other students that Dumbledore isn't as infallible as they thought. He could do this by revealing some of Dumbledore's past mistakes. Then, he could work on getting the school governors to question Dumbledore's leadership, gradually chipping away at his power and status within the wizarding community.