What makes the 'goat lady scary story' so terrifying?

Well, there are several things. Firstly, her pale complexion gives the impression that she is not of this world, perhaps a being from the afterlife. Secondly, she often appears unexpectedly, like in the middle of a dark forest or an old abandoned house. There's no warning, and suddenly you're face - to - face with this pale, ghostly figure. And finally, the stories associated with her are usually of a tragic nature, which adds to the overall sense of fear. People can't help but feel a bit of pity along with the terror, and this mix of emotions makes her all the more terrifying.

The 'Donkey Lady' scary story is terrifying because it plays on our fears of the unknown and the abnormal. Her inhuman form challenges our perception of what is normal and safe. The fact that she haunts certain areas at night, when we are already more vulnerable, heightens the fear. Moreover, the stories about her often lack a clear explanation for her existence. We don't know her motives or what she might do if she encounters someone. All these uncertainties and the grotesque image of her make the story extremely frightening.

The unknown elements make a scary story terrifying. When there are things that the characters and the readers don't understand, like a strange noise in the dark or a figure that appears and disappears without explanation, it creates fear. For example, in a haunted house story, if there are unexplained cold spots or voices, it gives a sense of unease.

Her appearance. The paleness of her skin makes her look sickly or otherworldly. And being fat gives her a certain bulk that can be intimidating, especially in the context of a spooky story.

Often in these stories, it's not just her physical appearance. It could be the mystery surrounding her. Maybe she has some dark secrets or a tragic past that adds to the fear factor. For example, if she's a ghost or a witch, that unknown element of what she might do is really scary. Also, the contrast between her appearance and the normal people in the story makes her stand out and seem more menacing.

The Paw Lady is terrifying because of her appearance. She might have a grotesque hand or paw - like feature that is just unnatural and makes people feel a sense of dread when they see it.

The idea of a wheelchair being scary is often because it's associated with the unknown. A moving wheelchair with no visible operator gives the impression of a ghostly presence.

The wendigo's appearance is very frightening. It is often described as extremely thin yet very tall with long limbs and sharp claws. Just the thought of such a grotesque creature lurking in the shadows can send shivers down your spine.

The unknown factor. In a scary online story, often we don't know where the threat is coming from. For example, in a story about a haunted website, you don't know what will happen when you click on a certain link. It could be anything, and that uncertainty is what scares us.

The Mothman's appearance. It has huge wings and glowing red eyes which are very unnatural and spooky.