What Makes a 'Harry Potter' Fanfiction the Best?

In my opinion, the best Harry Potter fanfictions are those that manage to be both familiar and novel. They should feel like they belong to the Harry Potter universe, so using the existing locations like Diagon Alley and Hogwarts in a natural way is important. At the same time, they need to bring something new to the table. This could be a new character arc for an existing character or a new magical creature. The fanfiction also has to be well - paced. If it drags on too long in one part or rushes through important events, it won't be as good. And the emotional impact is crucial. A fanfiction that can make the reader feel the same range of emotions as the original books, from excitement during a Quidditch match to sadness at the loss of a character, is more likely to be considered among the best.

One thing that can make a Harry Potter femslash fanfiction the best is how it explores themes that were either hinted at or completely new in the context of the female - female relationships. For example, if it's a story about Ginny and Luna, it could explore themes of female empowerment and friendship evolving into something more. It should also have a good plot. A fic that just focuses on the romance without a proper story arc can get boring. So, a balance between relationship development and an interesting plot is key.

A great Harry Potter and Avengers fanfiction often has a seamless blend of the two universes. For example, it might find a way to incorporate Hogwarts into the Avengers' world or vice versa. This could involve having Avengers characters learn magic at Hogwarts or Harry Potter characters using their magic to help the Avengers in a battle.

A great plot is crucial. For example, if it has a unique take on time - travel like in some fanfics where Harry gets to meet Lily in a different time period. This adds an exciting element to the story.

A great Harry Potter and Tom Riddle fanfiction often has well - developed characters. It takes the existing personalities of Harry and Tom from the original books and expands on them in interesting ways. For example, it might explore Tom Riddle's childhood more deeply and show how that influenced his later actions as Voldemort, while also showing Harry's growth in a new light. Also, a good plot is key. It could be a what - if scenario, like what if Harry and Tom had to team up at some point? That would create a really engaging and unique story.

A great Severus Snape fanfiction often delves deep into his complex character. It shows his inner turmoil, his love for Lily, and his conflicted relationship with Harry. If it can capture his snarky yet vulnerable side, it's a plus. For example, a story that shows his thoughts and feelings during his time as a double agent during the war is really interesting.

Another factor is the writing style. A good fanfiction uses vivid language to describe the magical elements and the detective work. It should also have a good flow, so that the reader can easily follow the story. The author might also add some unique twists, like how the two universes interact in unexpected ways. For instance, how Sherlock's rational thinking clashes or combines with the magic of the wizarding world.

A great Harry Potter Gabrielle Delacour fanfiction often has a well - developed character for Gabrielle. She should be in - character, with her Beauxbatons charm and her relationship with Fleur intact. Good writing style also matters. If the author can create a vivid picture of the wizarding world, especially the parts related to Gabrielle's story, like her experiences during the Triwizard Tournament or her life after, it makes the fanfic better. And of course, an interesting plot. It could be a story about Gabrielle's adventures post - Hogwarts, or her relationship with other characters from the Potterverse in a new and exciting way.

Well, a 'Best Comedy' Harry Potter fanfiction often has a unique take on the source material. It might exaggerate certain aspects of the wizarding world for comical effect. For example, the strictness of Snape could be over - the - top, and the students' attempts to outwit him could be really funny. Another factor is the use of pop - culture references in a way that blends well with the Harry Potter universe. If the author can make a joke about a modern - day meme but in the context of Hogwarts, it can be quite hilarious. Also, the pacing is important. Quick - paced humor with a series of comical events one after another can keep the reader entertained. And if it can make fun of some of the clichés in the Harry Potter series in a light - hearted way, that's a plus too.

A great Harry Potter fanfiction often has well - developed characters. It takes the existing characters from the books and either expands on them in a believable way or creates interesting new ones that fit into the wizarding world. For example, if it's a story about Harry's post - Hogwarts life, it should stay true to his character traits like his bravery and loyalty.