Analysis of 'Dumbledore Lied to Harry' in Fanfic

Yes, there might be. In the vast world of fanfiction, all sorts of creative and unexpected scenarios are explored. Some authors might come up with the idea of Dumbledore being afraid of Harry for various reasons. It could be due to Harry's newfound power that he doesn't fully understand, or perhaps a prophecy that takes an unexpected turn in the author's interpretation. Fanfic writers often like to play with the established characters' emotions and relationships in unique ways.

In some fan fictions, Dumbledore is depicted as manipulative. This often stems from his actions in the original series that could be seen as him using Harry for a greater good. For example, he didn't fully disclose information to Harry, which in fanfic interpretations might be seen as manipulation.

One possible view is that in some fanfictions, Dumbledore's manipulative side can be shown through his withholding of information from Harry. For example, he might keep secrets about Harry's past or his true destiny. This can add a layer of mystery and tension to the story.

Some fanfictions might explore a more nuanced past relationship between them. Maybe they had interactions in their younger days that shaped their future enmity. Dumbledore, with his deep understanding of magic and people, could have recognized the darkness growing in Voldemort early on and tried to guide him away from it, but Voldemort's pride and thirst for power made him reject any such guidance.

The 'female Harry Potter Dumbledore bashing fanfiction' may exist because some fans want to explore the darker sides of Dumbledore. When the main character is female, she might be written to have a more emotional and empathetic approach to the situations around her. This could lead to a more critical view of Dumbledore. For example, if Dumbledore knew about Harry's (or in this case, a female Harry's) difficult home life and still left him there, the female character could be more vocal about her dissatisfaction with Dumbledore's lack of intervention. It's a way for fans to rewrite the story according to their own interpretations.

Yes, there might be. The Harry Potter fandom is vast, and there could be fanfics with all sorts of creative and sometimes controversial plotlines like this. However, not all such fanfics are easy to find or of high quality. You'd need to search on popular fanfic platforms like Archive of Our Own or FanFiction.net.

It could be that Harry finds out about Dumbledore's secrets regarding the Deathly Hallows. If Harry thinks Dumbledore was more interested in the Hallows for his own purposes rather than for the greater good, it might make him hate Dumbledore.

The power dynamic also shifts. Usually, Dumbledore is seen as a mentor and a figure of authority. But when Harry denounces him, Harry is challenging that authority. In some fanfic, this could lead to a power struggle within the wizarding community as others take sides. It can also cause Harry to seek new allies who share his view of Dumbledore, changing the social fabric of the story.

Maybe Harry is under the influence of some dark magic or a powerful enemy who has tricked him. This enemy could have planted false memories in Harry's mind about Dumbledore. So, Harry, believing these false memories to be real, starts to expose Dumbledore as a villain based on these false recollections.

Perhaps Harry has been misled by someone he trusts. They could have filled his head with lies about Dumbledore, making Harry think that Dumbledore is actually a threat. And his motive would then be to protect the wizarding world from what he believes is a hidden danger in Dumbledore.