webnovel
Fanfiction about Snape and Harry involving corporal punishment: Is it appropriate?

Fanfiction about Snape and Harry involving corporal punishment: Is it appropriate?

2024-11-07 22:51
2 answers

It depends on how it's written. If the corporal punishment is used as a means to show the power dynamic between Snape, as a teacher, and Harry, as a student, and then later leads to character development and growth for both of them, it could be a valid storytelling device in fanfiction. But if it's just for shock value or to be gratuitously cruel, then it's not appropriate. Fanfiction should still uphold some moral and ethical standards, even if it's exploring darker themes.

Well, in the context of the Harry Potter world, corporal punishment is a rather dark and controversial topic. While some might argue that in the strict environment of Hogwarts it could be a plot device in fanfiction, it's not really in line with the more positive values the series promotes. However, if written in a way that explores the complex relationship between Snape and Harry, it could potentially be an interesting, though edgy, take on their interactions.

Harry Potter: Dimensional Wizard

Harry Potter: Dimensional Wizard

Edward was reincarnated into the world of Harry Potter, an act which excites him giving the fact that this was one of his favorite books. So, he embarks on the path of wizardry in the hope of discovering the way it works, the laws or theories that govern it; he wanted to find its essence. When Edward finally uncovers the answers to the question he pondered on, he suddenly thought to himself: "Since the world of Harry Potter is real, what about all the other anime, movies, games, and books that I read from my past life? And if they are indeed real, how I can I get there?" This story is an Infinite Stream novel where the mc travels through different anime and movie worlds acquiring various magical abilities and knowledge in order to become a supreme wizard that stands on the top of countless dimensions and universes. This is a wish-fulfillment and Mary Sue novel so read at your own risk, and stop complaining about it. This is not a villain story, more like a morally gray one. Warnings: The MC will spend a great deal of time in the Harry Potter World before going to other worlds. I have not decided whether the [Curse Child] is canon or not. I do not care what JK Rowling said. Although this fanfic will be a Harem, the mc will not have a thousand women. Most likely, I will write so that he has a certain relationship with some female characters, then he will leave her in her own universe. Only a few will follow him in his journey. Also, a few men will also be in his group. THIS IS NOT A YAOI. If you enjoy my writing, please go read my other novel. [Journey of the Fate Destroying Emperor] Although the story is slow in the beginning, it is worth the wait for the later plots. Also published on royalroad.com Go check out my Pa.tr.eon: .https://www.patreon.com/LazySageDao Or just go into the site and search for my author name (LazySageDao). So, go and support me if you can. Discord: https://discord.gg/bnsezTApeY Disclaimer: All the characters in this novel belong to JK Rowling, and I'm just using them to write my own story. If the creator of the cover wants me to remove it, comment so in one of the newest chapters.
Book&Literature
715 Chs

Is corporal punishment fanfiction appropriate?

The appropriateness of corporal punishment fanfiction is subjective. For some, it can be an interesting exploration of historical or fictional power dynamics within the safety of a fictional world. But for others, it can be disturbing due to the nature of corporal punishment. It should be clearly labeled so that readers can make an informed choice.

3 answers
2024-12-14 19:40

How can fanfiction about Snape and Harry with corporal punishment be made more acceptable?

One way is to focus on the aftermath. Show how the experience of corporal punishment makes Harry more determined to prove himself or change Snape's view of him. For Snape, it could lead to self - reflection on his teaching methods. Also, make sure to set the context clearly. Maybe Hogwarts has some archaic rules that Snape is reluctantly following, but he starts to question them because of his interaction with Harry.

3 answers
2024-11-07 23:50

Is corporal punishment appropriate in Avengers fanfic?

In my opinion, it's not suitable. The Avengers universe is about superheroes fighting for good, saving the world, and promoting positive values. Corporal punishment is a rather negative concept. If it were to be included in a fanfic, it would likely distort the essence of the Avengers and might not be well - received by the fan community. It could also lead to discomfort among readers who expect the stories to uphold certain moral and ethical standards.

1 answer
2024-12-07 12:30

Is supernatural corporal punishment fanfiction appropriate for all audiences?

No. Supernatural corporal punishment fanfiction often contains themes that can be disturbing or inappropriate for younger or more sensitive audiences. It may involve violent or non - consensual elements that are not suitable for general consumption.

3 answers
2024-10-25 07:48

What is corporal punishment fanfiction?

Corporal punishment fanfiction is a type of fictional writing within fanfiction. It involves the exploration of corporal punishment themes within the context of an existing fictional universe, such as a particular book series, movie franchise, or TV show. However, it's important to note that in many real - world settings, corporal punishment is a controversial topic as it involves physical harm. In fanfiction, it's a creative exploration but should still be approached with sensitivity.

3 answers
2024-12-17 06:35

Is 'corporal punishment mlp fanfic' appropriate for all ages?

No. While some 'corporal punishment mlp fanfic' might be written in a very mild and educational way, there could be others that are too intense or misinterpret the concept. Younger kids might not understand the nuances and could be scared or influenced in the wrong way.

3 answers
2024-11-18 20:10

Stories about corporal punishment in schools: Are they common?

It depends. In some developing areas, there may be more stories about it due to lack of proper teacher training and old - fashioned educational concepts. However, in many modern and well - regulated educational systems, such stories are relatively rare. Corporal punishment has been widely recognized as an ineffective and harmful method of discipline.

2 answers
2024-11-19 21:11

What is 'corporal punishment fiction' all about?

Corporal punishment fiction often involves fictional stories that revolve around the theme of corporal punishment. It might depict situations in educational settings like strict schools where students face corporal punishment, or in historical contexts where such practices were more common in society. However, it's important to note that in modern times, corporal punishment is widely considered unethical and is banned in many places.

3 answers
2024-12-15 10:30

Stories about corporal punishment in UK schools

Corporal punishment in UK schools has a long and complex history. In the past, it was quite common for teachers to use physical means like caning to discipline students. However, over time, there has been a growing recognition of the harm it can cause, both physically and psychologically. Many stories recall the fear and humiliation students felt when facing such punishments.

3 answers
2024-12-03 12:44

Fanfiction about Harry Potter and Severus Snape involving creatures

One possible fanfiction could be about Severus Snape discovering a new magical creature on the Hogwarts grounds and Harry Potter getting involved. Maybe it's a creature that has the power to heal dark magic wounds, and Snape initially wants to keep it a secret for his own reasons, but Harry stumbles upon it. They then have to work together to protect the creature from those who might want to use it for evil.

1 answer
2024-11-10 15:12
a
b
c
d
e
f
g
h
i
j
k
l
m
n
o
p
q
r
s
t
u
v
w
x
y
z