What makes a true scary story truly terrifying to tell?

The element of surprise and the unknown. When you don't expect what's coming and can't predict it, that's what makes a scary story truly terrifying.

For a scary story to be really terrifying when told, it needs elements like a creepy setting, mysterious characters, and a sense of impending doom. Also, using vivid descriptions to paint a vivid picture in the listener's mind helps a lot.

The element of surprise and the unknown often do the trick. When you don't know what's coming next, it amps up the fear factor.

A scary story becomes truly terrifying when it plays on our deepest fears. Maybe it's the fear of the dark, of being alone, or of something unknown lurking. Good use of sound and description to set the mood helps a lot too.

A good scary story usually has elements like a creepy setting, unexpected twists, and characters you can relate to but are in extreme danger.

Often, it's the reality and the fact that it actually happened that makes a true story terrifying. Knowing that these horrors are not just fictional but part of the real world can be very disturbing.

The element of psychological horror can make a scary story truly terrifying. It's not just about jump scares or monsters. It's about getting into the minds of the characters and feeling their fear, paranoia, and despair. For instance, a story where a character slowly loses their sanity can be very disturbing as it makes the audience question their own mental state and what they would do in such a situation.

A good scary short story often has unexpected twists and turns. It plays on common fears and builds tension gradually to shock the reader at the end.

A good long scary story often has a creepy setting. Maybe an abandoned house or a dark forest. Also, unexpected plot twists can add to the terror. And, of course, well-developed, sinister characters can make it really spine-chilling.

For a Halloween story to be scary, it needs a creepy setting, like an abandoned house or a dark forest. Also, having characters that are vulnerable and in constant danger adds to the terror. And don't forget the element of the supernatural or mysterious creatures.