The butcher would be the most terrifying. Just think about it. He works with sharp knives and has no qualms about using them on his victims. His profession gives him an edge in terms of being able to create a very gory and disturbing scene. Also, his character might be written in such a way that he has a cold, calculating look in his eyes and a menacing aura about him that makes him the most terrifying character in the story.
I think it's the butcher. Since it's 'the butcher american horror story', he's bound to be the scariest. He has the tools and the know - how to cause harm, and his very presence in the story is probably designed to instill fear.
One of the most terrifying moments is in 'Murder House' when the Rubber Man appears. His menacing look and the mystery surrounding him send chills down the spine. Another is in 'Asylum' with Bloody Face. The idea of a serial killer on the loose within the asylum is really scary.
Well, in 'Coven', the scene where the witches are facing the voodoo witches is quite terrifying. The intense magic battles and the dark spells being cast add to the horror. Also, the creepy dolls in some seasons can be really scary. They seem so innocent but are often associated with evil spirits or events in the show.
In 'Asylum', the Bloody Face scenes are quite terrifying. The idea of a serial killer lurking around in an already spooky asylum, especially when he reveals his true face covered in blood, sends shivers down the spine.
The Rubber Man scenes in the first season are really terrifying. His appearance is just so creepy.
The most terrifying moments often involve the unexpected twists. For example, in 'Murder House', the sudden appearances of the ghosts were really scary. You never knew when they would show up, like Tate's presence which was both menacing and unpredictable.
The Rubber Man in the first season is quite terrifying. His appearance, all in black rubber suit, is really spooky especially when he moves in that silent and menacing way.
One of the scariest things in American Horror Story is the psychological horror it presents. In Asylum, the way the patients are treated and the secrets hidden within the asylum walls create a sense of dread. The experiments done on the patients, the presence of the demonic entities, and the overall atmosphere of the place make it a breeding ground for terrifying moments. You can feel the characters' fear and it makes you on edge as a viewer.
The Rubber Man scenes in the first season are quite terrifying. Just seeing that figure in the latex suit lurking around is enough to give you chills.
The Rubber Man in the first season is really terrifying. His appearance with the shiny black latex suit and his silent stalking is quite spooky.
One of the most terrifying moments is in 'Murder House' when the Rubber Man appears out of nowhere. It's really creepy as he moves silently in that black, shiny suit.