What Are the Consequences of Dumbledore Lying to Harry in Fanfic?

One possible consequence is that Harry could put himself in danger. Dumbledore is usually very wise, and his advice is often meant to protect Harry. By not listening, Harry may walk into a trap or face a more difficult situation than he expected.

Snape might be given a warning by Dumbledore at first. Just a simple 'stop this behavior or else' kind of warning.

In fanfiction, when Harry doesn't trust Dumbledore, it often leads to a shift in the power balance. Harry might take more matters into his own hands, which could have both positive and negative outcomes. Positively, he could become more self - reliant and develop his own unique way of dealing with threats. Negatively, he could end up putting himself and others in more danger without Dumbledore's wisdom to guide him.

The consequences might include a change in the outcome of the fight against Voldemort. If Dumbledore's plan was a sure - fire way to defeat Voldemort in the long run, Harry derailing it could lead to either a more difficult victory or even a defeat. Also, Harry himself could face personal consequences. He might lose the trust of his friends who believed in Dumbledore's wisdom. His reputation in the wizarding world could be tarnished as people would think he was acting recklessly.

Yes, there might be. In the vast world of fanfiction, all sorts of creative and unexpected scenarios are explored. Some authors might come up with the idea of Dumbledore being afraid of Harry for various reasons. It could be due to Harry's newfound power that he doesn't fully understand, or perhaps a prophecy that takes an unexpected turn in the author's interpretation. Fanfic writers often like to play with the established characters' emotions and relationships in unique ways.

One consequence could be that other characters are put at risk. If Dumbledore had a plan to protect everyone and Harry messes it up, those protections might fail. For example, if Dumbledore planned a safe passage for a group and Harry's actions cause the enemies to discover it, the group could be in danger.

It could be that Harry finds out about Dumbledore's secrets regarding the Deathly Hallows. If Harry thinks Dumbledore was more interested in the Hallows for his own purposes rather than for the greater good, it might make him hate Dumbledore.

Perhaps Harry has been misled by someone he trusts. They could have filled his head with lies about Dumbledore, making Harry think that Dumbledore is actually a threat. And his motive would then be to protect the wizarding world from what he believes is a hidden danger in Dumbledore.

One possible reason for Dumbledore lying in fanfic could be related to his own past mistakes. He may have thought that by not telling Harry everything, he could guide Harry more subtly towards the ultimate defeat of Voldemort. However, this often creates a sense of betrayal for Harry in the fanfic, which adds a new layer of drama to the story.

Yes, there might be. The Harry Potter fandom is vast, and there could be fanfics with all sorts of creative and sometimes controversial plotlines like this. However, not all such fanfics are easy to find or of high quality. You'd need to search on popular fanfic platforms like Archive of Our Own or FanFiction.net.