A critic could also say this. When evaluating a piece of literature that has some American elements but falls short in certain aspects like character development or thematic depth, they may use this statement.
Even a reader could say it. If a reader has high expectations for what a great American novel should be and reads a book that doesn't fulfill those expectations, they might comment 'this is not the great american novel'.
An author who is modest about their work might say this. They might be aware that their writing doesn't have all the elements that are typically associated with a great American novel.
People say RDR2 is like a great American novel because of its epic scope. It has a large - scale story that spans different locations and time periods, much like how a great American novel might cover different regions and historical eras.
There's no definitive answer. Different people have different opinions on what constitutes the Great American Novel and who wrote it.
There are many novels considered as great American novels by different people. For example, Mark Twain wrote 'The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn', which is often regarded as a great American novel. It shows a vivid picture of American society along the Mississippi River at that time, with its unique characters and the exploration of moral and social issues.
Herman Melville is associated with it through 'Moby - Dick'. His work delved deep into the American psyche and the nature of man's obsession.
I have no idea who wrote 'b the great american novel' as it's not a well - known title in the form presented. There could be an indie author or it could be something very new and not yet widely publicized.
Jack Kerouac wrote 'On the Road'. It's considered one of his most famous works.
As mentioned before, Nathaniel Hawthorne could be considered as the author of a potential first great American novel with 'The Scarlet Letter'.
Herman Melville, who wrote 'Moby - Dick'. His work is a deep exploration of many themes and is often regarded in the conversation of the 'Great American Novel'.
As mentioned before, Nathaniel Hawthorne is often considered with his 'The Scarlet Letter'. His exploration of Puritanical themes was quite unique for American literature at that time.
As the title is rather unclear, it's difficult to determine the author. There might be an author named Roth, but without more context, it could be anyone. It could also be a relatively unknown author or a self - published work. If it is a well - known work associated with a major 'Roth', like Philip Roth, then he is the likely author.