Craiberk - Profile

Not your preferred language? Here to Choose your language.
Craiberk

Craiberk

LV 11
2018-02-20 Joined Global

Badges 5

Moments 18

Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Replied to Asura_Vajra
Okawaii koto!

ch 60 Chapter 60 - Old Man's Favor

Avatar: Awakened Gamer

Avatar: Awakened Gamer

Anime & Comics · HolyJoker

Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Craiberk
Replied to ghjiutrvb66
A review serves multiple purposes, from letting the author know what went wrong, which particular part of the story was contraversial, to notifying you and me that a novel has it's potential downsides. If you happen to be of the same mindset as the reviewer, you'll save yourself some time skipping the process of discovering how a story is not to your liking. In my opinion critique is much more valuable form of feedback than praise. Saying to not leave negative reviews is asinine. I am much more upset with all the pointless 5-star reviews of people either spamming random characters for the sake of farming pointless exp or going "I didn't read it, but it's in my favorite universe so I'm giving it 5 stars!" polluting this site. Furthermore, I find the statement of "why don't you make something better before criticizing someone else's work" to be idiotic to the extreme. It doesn't take the ability to create to find flaws in someone else's creation. It's like you get served rotten food in the restraunt and then getting "Hey! Why don't you go to a culinary school for half a decade and then work in a restraunt for two before you get to criticize my work?!" No, it doesn't work that way. You are spending a limited resource in the form of money (or time reading novel) and if you are served trash, you should be entitled to let people know. And no amount of "I'm a creator" is relevant. Not trashing the novel here, btw, just your bad ideas on how feedback and discourse should function.
Craiberk
Commented
There's one mistake that many authors are constantly making and I am hoping that this fic, being of a more well-thought through variety, may hopefully be able to avoid. Namely, even though the MC has introduced massive changes into the timeline, the exact same "next generation" as in cannon is born. To make my point a bit more clear, I propose the following. A single gamete contains 50% of mother's(or, more importantly for the purpose of this thought experiment, fathers) DNA that is required to complete the instruction sequence for a "human assembly". Combining mother's and fathers gametes produces a unique chain of proteines that determine future child's traits. Let's say for the sake of example that this is a day of future this hypothetical child's conception. In this scenario, a hypothetical future father is on his way to "provide the genetic material", as it were. While he is nearing home, our timeline divides in two. In the first sub-timeline the father reaches home without interruptions, does the deed and a sperm A, surrounded by billions of other similar sperms begin it's race to fertilize the egg, successfully finishes it, creating a child. In the second timeline, however, a weirdo pops out from around the corner, ambushing our future hypothetical dad with a statement that he is a reincarnator and a bunch of silly questions such as "what year it is" and "where exactly in this world said reincarnator saw as fantastical they are currently located", before running away and disappearing around the corner and from the scenario alltogether. Having answered his questions, the future dad upon returning home feels compelled to share this strange situation with his significant other before "proceeding to do the deed". This slight delay however has caused the ever-wriggling mass of male gametes to change their composition and now our sperm A is not in a position to win the race and instead it crawls in a completely different direction and a sperm B wins the race instead. Considering the fact that child's biological *** is determined solely by the male gamete, in a timeline One the kid may have been born as a boy, maybe having hated a certain other boy throughout his entire childhood, in timeline Two that child may have been born as a girl and had a crush on the same boy the child from timeline One hated all this time. And that's not going into other physical, social or mental characteristics that may or may not have been different. If such a tiny change in the sequence of events has deviated the scenario so much, how many tiny changes will there be if said reincarnator was present THE ENTIRE LIFETIME, being friends or enemies with the future dad, having one of his students survive instead of dying, stealing one of his favorite techniques and so on? Even if the Nine-Tails attack happens and goes on as it did in the cannon, Naruto may or may not be born a girl, a boy with his mother's hair color and father's intellect and disposition or even having been born with a variety of congenial deffects. Same goes for the rest of the main cast.
Craiberk
Report user