Reviews of Fallen Immortal Son: Rebirth in the World of Magic; A Cultivating Mage.

8 Reviews

  • Writing Quality
  • Stability of Updates
  • Story Development
  • Character Design
  • World Background

Share your thoughts with others

Write a review
Starcracker
Hey there! Good day for writing! If you wanted to see whether you can get paid by distributing the current work or getting financial support by writing new work, you might want to contact cttbx123@gmail.com. A brief introduction, some sample chapters or links will be appreciated when reaching out.
4mth
view 0 replies
DeJeL
LV 5

DeJeL

*Remember, this review is based on the first 5 chapters* Constructive Criticism: I suggest you just declare and go on a Hiatus until you have 10 chapters ready for us, then you publish them at a rate of one a week until either you are finished writing the story or feel that going back to one a day would still leave you plenty of room for the story. Also, in the first few chapters you give us information that we will need by just throwing us the information, not even relating it directly to the plot... I suggest you make it to where it's part of the MC's memories explained to us or the MC overhears someone else explaining the information, it flows more that way. Positive Feedback: up to the two most recent chapters, you did well with keeping your updates stable, also, you did let us know around the beginning of your gaps of updates why you had the gaps, good going there.;,;. also you have a good story that is well written, just not always well executed.;,;. Personal Feedback: I enjoy and will continue reading this novel. Score: SD 4/5 Rest 5/5
2yr
view 0 replies
Garthak
Can you please name him Ryu and not use the full name. 🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉🍉
2yr
view 0 replies
InfernalRhage
While this is definitely a promising novel there are a few flaws that I feel need to be addressed in order for it to reach its potential. Writing quality: 3/5- It may not be the worst novel I have read in terms of writing quality there are numerous grammatical and spelling errors throughout. Add in random missing words and it definitely leaves something to be desired. Stability of updates: 5/5- The author has given us 24 chapters in 13 days at this point with 2 chapters a day being the norm I have no complaints. Story Development: 4/5- While it is still early in the novel it seems to be developing at a steady pace. There are a few issues with the character development that could be fixed but nothing to major. Character Design: 1/5- The MC is in serious need of an overhaul. I swear this guys personality is like watching someone with multiple personality disorder. I get his soul is a fusion of two different people and he doesn't want to choose one personality over the other but come on. On one had you have the soul of a powerful sword immortal who once stood at the apex of cultivation, on the other the soul of a obese bullied cripple with no backbone. A proper fusion would give you a slightly arrogant attitude that is also willing to listen to reason. Instead what we get is your basic Japanese protagonist who lets his "teacher" walk all over him, while at other times he is vicious and uncaring such as the scenes where he is dealing with his bully's. This at times makes reading this story extremely painful. I'm sorry but with the history given for the MC he should in no way be such a passive beta. Then you got the recently introduced granddaughter of his "master" who upon seeing him in his slimmer form asks him to marry her. While this is understandable looks do influnce how people treat someone it goes as far as the girl who is 7 years younger than the MC getting aggressive with the MC's teacher who it states is like a big sister to her. This is in no way realistic you are not gonna risk ruining a relationship with someone who is like family for someone you just met minutes before. World Background: 4/5- While the world is still being revealed to us most of the info is given to us in chunks of authors notes at the begining of each chapter. Firstly these are distracting from the story and should be removed and placed in an auxiliary chapter. Next while you can say the MC didn't need to learn this due to the memories he gained during the soul fusion, I feel the need to point out you have stated the original soul of the body he is currently in was suffering from brain damage. Why would he just accept the information received from someone with brain damage without even trying to double check any of it I mean come on he is attending an academy how hard is it to visit the library and read a few books on the world he is living in? While it may seem like I am being unreasonable harsh in my review I got to say I really enjoyed the concept of this story and think that with some tweaks it would easily become a great novel.
2yr
view 6 replies
Melshan
Muito bom a novel recomendo à todos a acompanhar, não vão se arrepender. Muito bom a novel recomendo à todos a acompanhar, não vão se arrepender. 😎😎
2yr
view 0 replies
MIKMIK
imagine Japanese novel world with Chinese novel people in it and thats it!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
2yr
view 0 replies
babidikk
Fats2x convert to mana my god. I need to become fat so that i have mana also. Hahahahahaha dont mind me im a brainless heheheheh nice chapter
2yr
view 0 replies
The_Saint_of_Gods
Great story so far. Its finally at a good part can't wait for the next chapter. .
2yr
view 0 replies